Show of HandsShow of Hands

Show Of Hands February 19th, 2013 6:45pm

Should the U.S. refrain from taking a military action because the U.N. Security Council doesn't approve of it?

1 Liked

Comments: Add Comment

mmjman Emerald Valley
02/19/13 7:23 pm

Oops typo "security council disapproves"

FastFusion nj
02/19/13 7:22 pm

The United States should always act in its best interests with regard only for our closet allies (Israel and England).

Reply
mmjman Emerald Valley
02/19/13 7:22 pm

Respect doesn't mean treat like authority.

Heinrich13
02/19/13 7:21 pm

The US should not get in everyone else's business. If we are attacked we need to just blow the nation that attacked off the face of the earth problem solved. Who needs the Middle East anyway.

Reply
mmjman Emerald Valley
02/19/13 7:20 pm

I know there is no world government silly. I'm saying we should respect international law because I personally think many of them (like the rules set at the Geneva convention) are things we should be doing no matter what, regardless what the international community thinks.

Reply
mmjman Emerald Valley
02/19/13 7:19 pm

If the UN should have veto power over our military action then heck no. If god forbid we ever do need to act and the security council approves it I would hope we act

mmjman Emerald Valley
02/19/13 7:18 pm

Actually let me kinda clarify. In most cases yeah we probably should but not because we should allow the UN to have authority over us but because unilateral military engagement rarely solves anything, and is usually not necessary. (Hence why no-one will go in with us. If the question is asking

elyonia679
02/19/13 7:17 pm

it all depends on the situation. we definitely don't want another Vietnam. I think the only time the American armed forces should get involved is when life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness is at stake.

Reply
TempName14 Everywhere but nowhere
02/19/13 7:17 pm

There is no world government. The US is sovereign. What you call "international law" is simply the set of rules the US voluntarily agrees to follow as established by treaties ratified by our congress.

Reply
Heinrich13
02/19/13 7:17 pm

The UN is BS and should be desolved it is too liberal and countries should do what they want without the UN butting in.

Reply
DerekWills Lone Star Gun Rights
02/19/13 7:14 pm

The UN has been a joke since its inception in 1945. Prior to that, the League of Nations was just as much of a joke. It's just another meaningless body meant to provide the illusion of security. If countries want to talk, they have Ambassadors. You know, like Chris Stevens in Benghazi, Libya....

Reply
mmjman Emerald Valley
02/19/13 7:14 pm

No. Should we respect international law and take into account the opinion of the international community? Absolutely. But the only one who should have the final say about our military action is us. I would hope we never act unilaterally though.

Reply
argeas Arnor
02/19/13 7:12 pm

You obviously have no idea how the UN security council works. Any of the five permanent members of the council (US, UK, France, China, Russia) can veto any UNSC resolution for any reason. This kills the resolution dead. No 2/3 overrule like congress.

Reply
ArechiDan Post Apocalyptic America
02/19/13 7:12 pm

The largest periods of growth in human history have followed global conflicts, do you think this is a coincidence?

Reply
longhorn1 Kindocologist Hater
02/19/13 7:12 pm

At this point...I think we should refrain from military action if anyone asks, much less the UN.

However, if Canada says so much as a word, we should turn that whole place into another state.

Reply
ArechiDan Post Apocalyptic America
02/19/13 7:11 pm

War is a nessacary mechanism in our global system.

World peace is unrealistic, the simple fact that people have thier own opinions promises this ongoing fact.

Reply
makem Chinese Xinjiang Camp
02/19/13 7:10 pm

No, for the sole fact that we will do it anyway

mccougar
02/19/13 7:09 pm

Look how that has worked in the past!
Name one time when we didn't have their approval and it wasn't something we should have done?

Reply
ArechiDan Post Apocalyptic America
02/19/13 7:09 pm

The truth is we ARE already one group and guess what? Some of us dont like the others based on difference and materials possed.

I would like to hear one realistic idea besides an attack from outside our planet that will unite us all under this one fluffy unrealistic banner of love...

TempName14 Everywhere but nowhere
02/19/13 7:09 pm

To be clear, keep the cool weapons programs, research, keep the military strong, just scale down for the role of defense instead of world policing.

Reply
robolds Initiative
02/19/13 7:09 pm

Amen brother!

Reply
Misterme7 Under the Rainbow
02/19/13 7:08 pm

I said yes, but I think we might take it. I just think we should think it over more carefully if they don't recommend it before we actually do it.

TempName14 Everywhere but nowhere
02/19/13 7:08 pm

I'm a former Marine and a die-hard conservative and I'm frankly tired of attacking.

How about we close all our foreign bases, shrink the military to the size suitable for national defense, not world policing\domination, mind our business, and pay down the deficit?

Reply
kongster unchained
02/19/13 7:07 pm

I voted no but not BECAUSE of the UN
Because we should stop taking military actions period

JimmyRustles
02/19/13 7:04 pm

The UN is not American and therefore should not decide on American issues

Reply
ArechiDan Post Apocalyptic America
02/19/13 7:04 pm

Better to attack than defend, this is basic BASIC strategy.

The only way we will EVER have no need of our armies and there wars is if people like YOU can convince our enimies to love us.

....and yea...good luck with that one -_-

alyse
02/19/13 7:03 pm

The UN is trying to protect the world from another world war. You think we'll all have justice and freedom once another world war breaks out?

Reply
DunkinFrunk Austin area, Texas
02/19/13 7:02 pm

Screw Iran and North Korea as well

Reply
veritas1 Panda
02/19/13 6:59 pm

…said Iran and North Korea.

Reply
Doopy Remedial Americanism
02/19/13 6:58 pm

Aww, heck with the Klingons! You blow up one little outlying moon...

Reply
DunkinFrunk Austin area, Texas
02/19/13 6:57 pm

Screw the U.N. we don't need their approval or support.

Reply
smarttexan2 Extremism Harms
02/19/13 6:56 pm

Great point. Don't follow anybody blindly.

balugadofis FOR MINECRAFTIA
02/19/13 6:53 pm

Yes I know, but you will notice that the three main axis powers: Nazi Germany, Japan, and Italy, all left it around 1935. These countries were the aggressors and had been ignoring it for a long time. I see a connection, albeit a non major one.

Reply
Zack100 Tatooine
02/19/13 6:53 pm

We shouldn't be taking military action in the first place. Get the hell out of everyone's business, America. We dont need to be spending money to help other countries when we need help even more.

Reply
swjboucher Just Run
02/19/13 6:53 pm

Not sure what your point is but..
Germany did not follow the military they followed a leader that had promised them hope and change for a new Germany.

Reply
ArechiDan Post Apocalyptic America
02/19/13 6:52 pm

The UN needs to be abolished, the system of globalizm is a tyranical machine that needs to be wiped from the face of the earth.

Liberty,freedom,and justice...FOR ALL.

Reply
dabomb
02/19/13 6:50 pm

Not if they just disapprove. Maybe if it was a definitive "no."

robolds Initiative
02/19/13 6:49 pm

I mean, What if we had listened to the Natzis back in the 30s and 40s? Like their people did so blindly supporting their military!

smarttexan2 Extremism Harms
02/19/13 6:48 pm

No - we are a sovereign country. We should consider the opinions of our allies but we have to act independently, in the best interests of the American people. Now if congress would just act in our interests!

Reply
wetheslaves Live each moment fully
02/19/13 6:48 pm

Not all actions are known or go through regular approval channels. We have many ways to skin a cat.

bobi
02/19/13 6:47 pm

Why? So we can fight the Klingons?

Reply
roybiker12
02/19/13 6:46 pm

Stop sending our tax money to the UN.

Reply
tmacsurprise no pictures just numbers
02/19/13 6:46 pm

We bow to NONE!!! F@&! The UN we should never ask permission

Reply
chemist1
02/19/13 6:45 pm

The UN is a joke. When CHINA of all countries is on the human rights commission, how can you take them seriously?

Reply
curtron basement of the Alamo
02/19/13 6:45 pm

We should just mind our own business period

Reply
JPolgarFan
02/19/13 6:44 pm

Actually its quite an enlightened statement. Clearly above your head.

Reply
robolds Initiative
02/19/13 6:44 pm

Ok, all of you that say yes, how about "should the US take military action if the UN says we should?" C'mon, we don't cow tow to the UN! They don't have our best interests in mind.

Reply