Show of HandsShow of Hands

Show Of Hands February 10th, 2012 12:00am

Would Israel be justified in launching a pre-emptive military attack against Iran's nuclear facilities?

1 Liked

Comments: Add Comment

02/11/12 7:19 am

Mixhead i read the article and I can see your point. But there is no reason Israel should not blow up their nuclear weapons. So what i a dozen Jews the NY Times interviewed liked it there? Iran is still clearly planning on blowing up Israel and the U.S.

mixhead Oregon
02/11/12 7:17 am

I dont care to defend Iran. I only care to defend the search for truth in the mess of media lies and war propaganda in these matters. Like I said, the interpretation has a debate surrounding it. When you read deep into it, it's not as clear as the politicians made it out to be..

Malekithe My pronouns are GFY
02/11/12 7:15 am

In the end, Israel will act in its own interests (as it has before) and strike. The world will condemn them, while most decent nations, secretly thank them (including Arab nations who would never admit it) and then move on.

Justus Pensacola, FL
02/11/12 7:15 am

Stating Iran may be building a bomb. Thanks @hanis for the link.

Justus Pensacola, FL
02/11/12 7:14 am

@pollmd: the IAEA has made a report

Malekithe My pronouns are GFY
02/11/12 7:11 am

Poll is incorrect in his interpretation.
It a good debate and i do not fault anyone whose information is limited to google and wikipedia. You don't know what you don't know. Poll also agreed that if they were pursuing nuclear weapons, israel would be justified.

02/11/12 7:09 am

Mixhead he has quote said "Israel will disappear from the map". He denies the Holocaust too, a tragedy that resulted in the murder of 6,000,000. Please tell me why you are defending this horrible and sick man?

mixhead Oregon
02/11/12 7:04 am

Sorry for that miss-type but it doesn't change the concept. A journalist visited Iranian Jews and reported on their lifestyles and thoughts. You can find that documentary on YouTube.

Malekithe My pronouns are GFY
02/11/12 7:04 am


Quite peacefully is not exactly true. The religion is not recognized, provided over by Muslims and they have been persecuted frequently.

02/11/12 7:03 am

Dude he has said it in public numerous times. Why are you defending a badshit crazy guy?

02/11/12 7:02 am

I would like to see a legit argument as to why israel should not attack, but wait, there is none.

mixhead Oregon
02/11/12 7:01 am

Pollmd is actually correct pointing out the translation of the "wiping Israel off the map" has a lively debate surrounding it. Not only the words being off but the context of how he was actually quoting someone else.

Google it!

War Propaganda is a powerful tool.
Always question it, people die.

02/11/12 7:01 am

@Mixhead i have no idea where you get your facts from. Over 250,000 Jews living in Iran? Seriously? You are just making yourself sound even more stupid than you already are. All sources say there are <25,000 Jews there.

mixhead Oregon
02/11/12 6:46 am

@DiJitiL If Iran hates Jews as much as Hitler, then why haven't they killed off the 250,000+ Jews that live in their own country quite peacefully?

DavesNotHere where am I
02/11/12 5:46 am

They have the right to ensure their survival as much as any other country would. Irans leaders have vowed to destroy Israel. They hate Jews as much as Hitler did. Israel needs to prevent Iran from starting a nuclear war. What country wouldn't ?

barbearnj Dreaming of Banff
02/11/12 5:44 am

Absolutely! Go for it. It's not like Bebe et al get much support from our feckless administration!

Malekithe My pronouns are GFY
02/11/12 5:42 am

If Israel was the US and Iran was Cuba, what would we 1) negotiate 2) Sing "imagine" over and over to them. 3) assume they are not trying to develop nukes. 4) Strike to protect ourselves?

02/11/12 4:48 am

With sufficient evidence, which I believe there is, yes

02/11/12 4:44 am

For all who point to the myth that the IAEA claims Iran isn't building a bomb... Read below from their report that can be found in full at

02/11/12 4:42 am

33 Since 2002, the Agency has become increasingly concerned about the possible existence in Iran of undisclosed nuclear related activities involving military related organizations, including activities related to the development of a nuclear payload for a missile.

02/11/12 4:42 am

38. Previous reports by the Director General have identified outstanding issues related to possible military dimensions to Iran’s nuclear programme and actions required of Iran to resolve these.

02/11/12 4:19 am

Don't be sad. Mankind is designed to compete and do battle. Everything we do is competitive and argumentative... Just read the posts here. Just pray that the liberals don't put this country in a position where we can no longer take care of business.

spoiler Michigan
02/11/12 4:05 am

These results make me sad. Hasn't humanity seen enough blood shed? Imagine what we could accomplish if conflict wasn't part of our human condition

two.tired California
02/11/12 3:18 am

Nuke the whole damn middle east and turn it into the world's biggest sheet of glass. Then we can start fresh.

02/11/12 3:07 am

Therefore Israel has the same conservative mentality as conservative christians. The only difference is that the Jew believe from the Old Testament.

02/11/12 3:06 am

Oh ya and those over 40 years of age who said yes. They will never forget the nuclear arms race between the USSR and the US during the Cold War.

02/11/12 3:04 am

I thought Republicans that are Christian conservatives believed that Jesus taught us not to fight against each other.

waaazzaap Arizona
02/11/12 1:23 am

Nuclear weapons are very complex specific materials that I am sure Iran can't acquire whatsoever ! And also Iran's Army and their weapons are all old weapons from the past or terribly made domestic weapons , Iran really is defenseless , but unfortunately Israel is a nation built to survive on wars'

waaazzaap Arizona
02/11/12 1:19 am

You hit Iran , you make an already unstable region more unstable , this will result in Iran firing back their Rockets , perhaps attacking 'Israel' through the sea , but that's pretty much it .. Most of those who are afraid of Iran getting nukes are either stupid or retarded ,

02/11/12 12:53 am

Cherynoble heart. Argument over.

02/10/12 11:52 pm

I don't think anyone on SOH is qualified to make this judgement, unless we have some senior intelligence officers in our community (which would be really cool even though they wouldn't be at liberty to discuss anything)

02/10/12 11:03 pm

I wish they would. My mom is Arab, and she cant wait for Israel to take out Iran

pollmd Maryland
02/10/12 10:53 pm

Do you read Arabic? Have you read his statements in context?

Malekithe My pronouns are GFY
02/10/12 10:41 pm

Do you read Arabic?
Have you seen or read the original speech? You can believe what you wish. That does not make it correct.

02/10/12 10:36 pm

Iran has invited an attack with their rhetoric.

pollmd Maryland
02/10/12 10:35 pm

@Malekithe, that IS what Iran is saying. Listen to any full interviews with Ahmadinejad on Israel.

sohuser California
02/10/12 10:30 pm

Why not? They attacked Iraq's nuclear facilities, and everyone denied it ever happened.

02/10/12 10:28 pm

If I was Israel and had to deal with Muslims threatening my religion and home I'd attack too most likely.

02/10/12 10:26 pm

pollmd; why are we and the rest of the world engaging in all of the boycotts etc if we aren't trying to stop this dangerous activity? Your comments make no sense unless you are an Irainian yourself? Just spreading some disinformation? Got it.......

Malekithe My pronouns are GFY
02/10/12 10:25 pm


That is not what Iran is saying at all.

Malekithe My pronouns are GFY
02/10/12 10:23 pm

Your analogy is horribly flawed.
Your information on intelligence reporting is not accurate.

pollmd Maryland
02/10/12 10:16 pm

@Malekithe Imagine someone wishing for the US to be destroyed. Now imagine someone wishing for the Democrats and their policies to end and be replaced. Iran is saying the latter.

pollmd Maryland
02/10/12 10:12 pm

How many times must I say that US intelligence and the IAEA have said they ARE NOT MAKING A BOMB. When they are, it'll be a different story.

Malekithe My pronouns are GFY
02/10/12 10:07 pm


What exactly is the difference in "ending the regime" and "erasing from the pages of history"?

02/10/12 10:01 pm

Pollmd: you are a real dreamer. We would all like to believe the things you say but actions speak louder then words and Iran has been acting like they are a force to be dealt with. What scary about them is their leadership will sacrifice everything!

pollmd Maryland
02/10/12 9:50 pm

They already have enough uranium to build a bomb. Any country that pursues nuclear energy will eventually have enough. However, thats why we have the IAEA to monitor their nuclear materials and facilities.