Show of HandsShow of Hands

Show Of Hands July 7th, 2012 12:00am

Who is the better movie Spider-man: Tobey Maguire or Andrew Garfield? (UserQ)

1 Liked

Comments: Add Comment

Caulfield Utah
07/07/12 5:05 pm

Tobey Macguire was awful. Lately, this app is just reminding me how far America has fallen. Culturally, and politically.


07/07/12 4:38 pm

@ the only reason they made a new one is to use the actor In The avenger movies

spoiler Michigan
07/07/12 4:25 pm

The new spiderman was awesome! Way more like the comics. Tobey maguire was way too sappy and depressing at times.

Dmanddog
07/07/12 4:23 pm

Hatsune Andrew is from the new one

KudosToYou California
07/07/12 4:19 pm

Saw the new Spiderman movie today. I knew that even before seeing the movie that Garfield would be better than McGuire, and I was right.

cato Santa Barbara, California
07/07/12 3:01 pm

Saw the new spiderman today. Suck city!! Way too long.

truth1 Florida
07/07/12 2:23 pm

I vote against Toby. The new looks awful, yet still better than toby

SoL Ohio
07/07/12 2:14 pm

It's too soon for this question. The movie has only been out two days.

leDuck
07/07/12 1:49 pm

Tobey was terrible. The last 3 movies were bad. New Spiderman was great and Garfield did a fantastic job. That's it.

burnsey89 Louisiana
07/07/12 1:03 pm

Slxpluvs, I can see the emo thing, but I really liked it, nonetheless.

brettshel Bernie Would Have Won
07/07/12 12:46 pm

I feel this question was asked too early. Not everyone has had a chance to see the new movie. Although, I can tell you that Andrew Garfield is WAY better than McGuire. Toby didn't even look or act like Spider-Man.

nobodyspec
07/07/12 12:21 pm

Anyone who knows anything about spiderman should be saying Garfield. Mcguires spiderman wasnt even a shadow of the spidey from the comics.


07/07/12 12:01 pm

YOU MUST BE JOKING. Tobey was terrible and Garfield was terrific

lmurder MDK
07/07/12 11:19 am

Tobey sucks. The only reason he got that role was because he was banging one the elite film Jews daughters in hollywoodland.
Meyer....

JaquesV Bentonville, AR
07/07/12 11:06 am

TM was horrible so the new guy has to be better.

RepubIican South east
07/07/12 11:03 am

Andrew Garfield's was about 1000% better, so much more true to the comics, Spider-Man was sassy and obnoxious, and so is Garfield.


07/07/12 10:36 am

I'd have to say Andrew just for the fact that he plays the nerdy side much better. spiders are supposed to be agile and scrawny. Andrew plays that pretty well when compared to Tobey, he doesn't have the 'spider' look to him like Andrew does.

lswan13
07/07/12 10:25 am

Andrew played the part so much better than Tobey. The new movie was better than the old ones, because it stays true to the origins. It was just an all-around better cast this time too.

mama3
07/07/12 10:17 am

I liked Andrew better. He was a cool nerd as opposed to Tobey whose character lacked a little substance.

Gingerred primum non nocere
07/07/12 10:09 am

I was never satisfied with Tobey as Spiderman. Andrew seems much more suited to the part. Not to mention he did most of his own stunts, which is pretty impressive to me after seeing the new movie.

TheMadScientist the mad laboratory
07/07/12 10:03 am

Burnsey89, Indeed I was being ironic. Andrew is much too emo for the role.

fadinho michigan
07/07/12 9:37 am

Why even make a new Spiderman movie? Nothing was wrong with the first one.

MrNarwhal1 Naperville
07/07/12 9:37 am

I don't think anyone can beat the original, but I was pleased with Andrew Garfield's portrayal of the web slinging hero

burnsey89 Louisiana
07/07/12 9:22 am

Slxpluvs, are you talking about the new movie? Because there wasn't a lot of sleeping, no lasagna, and I can't recall one Monday joke.

burnsey89 Louisiana
07/07/12 9:20 am

Andrew and this entire production were ten times better than the previous. At least.

Hawkn Texas
07/07/12 9:18 am

Why have a reboot so soon? What if in three years there's a new Batman series "The Man of Bat" or something. And instead of Christian Bale it's Danny Devito. Or maybe instead of "Finding Nemo" they could make "The Finding of Nemo"
How about "The Titanic"? It would crash into a giant squid this time

TheMadScientist the mad laboratory
07/07/12 9:18 am

I think we all agree. Toby was a terrible Spiderman. Garfield is worse. All he does is sleep and eat lasagna. And he keeps going with the Monday jokes.


07/07/12 9:17 am

Has the new movie released yet? I cant make a decision until i see it.

monkeyy Ohio
07/07/12 9:04 am

I like Tobey in the movies. I haven't seen the new one so I am going with him.

alvinblack ur mum
07/07/12 8:55 am

spider is suppost to be small and nerdy

Meister
07/07/12 8:50 am

Andrew Garfield portrays the teenage angst so well and incorporates humor!

Zod Above Pugetropolis
07/07/12 8:44 am

I haven't yet seen the new movie, but the trailers look great. I never liked Tobey Maguire as Spiderman - he just comes across as too much of a needy wuss and didn't really capture the humor of the old comic book character.

KudosToYou California
07/07/12 8:42 am

Tobey McGuire was a terrible Spiderman. He ruined those movies just like he'll ruin The Great Gatsby.

lastjedi Florida, US
07/07/12 8:39 am

I like the new face of Spidey way more. The old one looked too nerdy for this storyline.

GirlOnFire Ohio
07/07/12 8:25 am

Well I haven't seen the new movie so I'm going with Tobey.

smtimberman
07/07/12 8:20 am

The new movie isn't just a tweak on the old ones. It's a completely different alternative universe. Spiderman and Amazing Spiderman are different comics. Also, AS is way better of a movie than the first three. And I mean WAAAAAYYYYY better!

jld32188
07/07/12 8:17 am

I think it's so dumb that they're remaking three perfectly good movies with slight tweaks closer following the comic book.


07/07/12 8:16 am

I used to be Octavius now I am Suleiman. I'm just saying random crape until the debate actually starts

optimist6 Fort Wayne, IN
07/07/12 8:02 am

Haha I can change my entire state from 100% red to 100% blue!