id Software Showdown! Doom vs. Quake!
You're gonna make me choose?!
Love both but doom was my first PC game.
Doom by far. Quake was a big disappointment...it didn't move as fast or as smooth, the frags weren't as satisfying, and everything was a dreary brown.
Romero actually wanted to go in a radically different direction...to have much fewer enemies but more involved and gory battles. It didn't work out, and Carmack eventually forced id to do another game like Doom. That's why its design is so uninspired...id lost its creativity when they forced Romero out.
Both classics but I’ll go Doom