Show of HandsShow of Hands

Show Of Hands January 12th, 2013 12:00am

Actress Quvenzhané Wallis, who was 6 years old when "Beasts of the Southern Wild" was filmed, has been nominated for a Best Actress Oscar. Some critics have argued that kids so young aren't really acting, but instead are just "subjects" of the director an

1 Liked

Comments: Add Comment

susanr Colorado
01/18/13 8:16 pm

I had to look them up: Oldest best in leading role: Henry Fonda 76, Jessica Tandy 80; oldest best in supporting role: Christopher Plummer 82, George Burns 80, Peggy Ashcroft 77. A bunch of others in their 70s. Only *nominee* older than these: best leading actress Emmanuelle Riva 85.

Lovil
01/18/13 5:33 am

susanr - Do you know any of their names? Just curious. Peter Fonda?

chocstina Georgia
01/16/13 12:35 am

you need to be slapped. just because her beautiful name isn't to your eurocentric ideals doesn't mean you can be an ass about it

Reply
staygolden
01/15/13 5:59 pm

She played the part. She gets the award. simple as that

Reply
JackTorS Clap you stupid bastards
01/15/13 5:18 pm

Yeah. Now my feelings are REALLY hurt! ????

Reply
hexin Wisconsin
01/15/13 4:36 pm

I find it funny that society doesn't consider children as people.

Reply
susanr Colorado
01/14/13 4:57 pm

It's older than anyone who has actually won (yet), but that doesn't mean it couldn't happen. There have been several people in their 80s.

penguins511
01/14/13 3:42 pm

If your 100 is that too old?

zorthog The Republic
01/14/13 12:02 pm

Thanks blue. btw to be grammatically correct next time you should say most stupid comment vice stupidest.

bluecanoe
01/14/13 11:50 am

You get a medal for stupidest comment, zort.

bluecanoe
01/14/13 11:48 am

That's a juvenile comment, select. Uncalled for!

bluecanoe
01/14/13 11:46 am

The first part of her name is a combo of the first few letters in each of her parents first names, with the Swahili word for spirit added to Quven.

bluecanoe
01/14/13 11:43 am

She was phenomenal as Hushpuppy, and I hope she wins!

KAnne Atlantic City, NJ
01/14/13 12:36 am

She's nine... We have no idea what she'll be like as a teenager or adult.

Leandra
01/13/13 10:53 pm

Perhaps if they were talking specifically about that child actor. But in their answer they were saying generally, if a child does better than expected, they should be able to get a reward.

Reply
chile safer than congress
01/13/13 10:45 pm

If you haven't seen the movie, then It just sounds like ignorance to me.
Come back and share your thoughts after watching

wears Tennessee
01/13/13 9:10 pm

Wasn't that que already asked?

pixcat Texas
01/13/13 8:39 pm

Remember Shirley Temple? She was very young, too.

AnnieM The Island
01/13/13 7:36 pm

but to my ears/eyes all their names seem like they very well could have roots, if not direct meanings, in Swahili).

AnnieM The Island
01/13/13 7:36 pm

that I once knew that spoke Swahili as a first language.
Apparently her name is pronounced quwa-VEN-zhahn-ay (zh=a similar sound to 'j', but not quite.) Her parents and siblings seem to have similar Swahili-sounding names (I'm not as familiar with Swahili as I could be, …

AnnieM The Island
01/13/13 7:35 pm

Yeah, I couldn't help doing some research on her name because it intrigued me. I can't find any record of it being used other than her & in an interview she said the "-zhané" part is Swahili for "fairy." I can't find any corroboration for that & I, unfortunately, have lost contact with the people…

Rio76 Wild West
01/13/13 6:50 pm

My son began acting in school and school plays at this age, and he was amazing. It may be unusual, but there are some kids out there who have an amazing gift of acting early in life.

Reply
Rio76 Wild West
01/13/13 6:46 pm

My son was an amazing actor at a very early age, and started performing on stage around this age. It's not as if they are a baby and used as a prop. At 6, I would day there is some acting involved.

Reply
sydwel
01/13/13 5:38 pm

I haven't seen the film so I cant judge. She clearly has some talent. However, I do believe at such a young age, she was probably just obeying instructions, instead of channeling an inner ability.

Reply
dlaw4570
01/13/13 2:37 pm

Like many questions, and certainly most entertainment awards...who cares?

fire4life Narnia
01/13/13 2:31 pm

The kid isn't a robot! She might be being told what to do but SHE is still portraying the part HERSELF. The director can't do that for her.

Reply
cheeseontop FactsOverFeelings
01/13/13 1:47 pm

Who cares? The Oscars are rigged anyway.

Reply
thenameis
01/13/13 1:13 pm

She was really good! Doesn't matter the age.

Reply
olive111
01/13/13 1:12 pm

YIKES! that's kinda sad. She worked just as hard if NOT harder because she is a child. She is no less an actor because she is 6.

PartyFree Nowhere in Particular
01/13/13 12:55 pm

It's a Sunday afternoon... obviously nothing better to do.

Reply
PartyFree Nowhere in Particular
01/13/13 12:54 pm

The only thing I could focus on with this question was the girl's name. Such an exotic first name, and then the last name of... Wallis? What a letdown.

As for the Oscars, they are an award voted by the industry for the industry. If they want to nominate and vote for a 6-year-old, then let them.

Reply
selectyour San Diego
01/13/13 12:19 pm

She's going to grow up to be a snobby bitch.

Reply
angiebrite Gallifrey
01/13/13 11:57 am

@kyonkichi No, a degree does not make me an expert. But since acting is my profession I do have a professional grasp on definitions of what it is I do. Tell me, how does one become an expert actor?

Kyonkichi Memphis
01/13/13 11:47 am

Lol, angiebrite, four years of undergrad clearly does not make you an expert. You sound very textbook.

deliala919 hashtag nerdy
01/13/13 11:44 am

No way! She can totally get an oscar! The directors arent putting the emotion on her face, they arent saying her lines! Doesnt matter how old, they can still get one O_O

jered
01/13/13 10:43 am

The Oscars is a big circle jerk for the entertainment industry. Why anyone else should care is beyond me. They've duped consumers into thinking these awards are important.

Rotten Tomatoes is a far better indicator of good films and actors.

Reply
Axl752 NY
01/13/13 10:30 am

Giving a six year old the oscar is like giving Lassie an oscar for doing a good job portraying a dog.

Reply
JackTorS Clap you stupid bastards
01/13/13 10:24 am

Yeah. Now my feelings are hurt.

Reply
CTYankee!!! Connecticut
01/13/13 10:17 am

An animal?!?
Do you have a child?

Reply
dadstad Texas
01/13/13 10:09 am

In the grand scheme does it matter? Does Hollywood matter?

Reply
zorthog The Republic
01/13/13 9:44 am

A 6 year old "actor" is nothing more than a trained animal.

Reply
Axl752 NY
01/13/13 9:10 am

At six years old kids arent even aware of whats going on. She doesnt deserve it. Give it to a real actress who has spent years perfecting her craft.

Reply
pjatx Austin, TX
01/13/13 9:02 am

There seems to be a lot of people who "couldn't care less about hollywood" taking time out of their day to vote and comment on a non-scientific pole. Just sayin'.

Reply
timeout Boston Strong
01/13/13 8:19 am

She is definitely the Youngest ever. Tatum O'Neal won at ten. I've only seen clips but she certainly grabs your attention. I say she qualifies.

Reply
soupy Ohio
01/13/13 8:16 am

they are just mad that they got beat by a 6 year old

Reply
leary Dulag Luft
01/13/13 8:16 am

The Oscars are to generate interest and theatre traffic.