Show of HandsShow of Hands

Mattwall1 October 31st, 2013 9:59pm

Two high school teen guys take photos of themselves and forward to a few classmates. Some of the girls forward them to their friends. The school finds out, gets the police, and all the girls are charged with child porn. Was this the right call?

22 Liked

Comments: Add Comment

Ebola1 Florida
11/02/13 1:02 pm

I'm not sure why the were charged with porn. The question doesn't mention anything inappropriate about the photos?

Redacted
10/31/13 4:39 pm

It doesn't say *only* the girls are charged. Everyone involved should be in trouble but not as far as charged with child porn.

Reply
skinner Wisconsin
10/31/13 5:31 pm

You're right. The guys will also be charged with production and distribution of child pornography

GotHeem Indiana
10/31/13 3:58 pm

They should both get punished

Reply
skinner Wisconsin
10/31/13 5:31 pm

You're right. The guys will also be charged with production and distribution of child pornography

Zod Above Pugetropolis
10/31/13 3:46 pm

Dumb as it sounds, yes. Assuming the boys are underage, the boys and the girls are equally guilty. On the stupid technicality. Our grizzled old lawmakers forget boys and girls have been playing "I'll show you mine if you'll show me yours" forever.

Reply
doctalk not all who wander r lost
10/31/13 5:11 pm

Thank you Zod. Sexual curiosity is pretty natural.

firefly5 the verse
11/01/13 10:18 pm

yes, but letting it go sets a very dangerous precedent.

Mattwall1
10/31/13 3:35 pm

I switched the riles from shazam's case

spicysteve M14D SBS
10/31/13 3:19 pm

If they received it, and deleted them, the girls wouldn't get in trouble. In my opinion, the fact that they transmitted the a round to everyone makes thm guilty

Reply
FIAT2LUX On Planet Earth
10/31/13 3:05 pm

Assuming that they were nude pictures, then yes, that should be charged as child porn.

Reply
Mattwall1
10/31/13 3:01 pm

Inspired by shazam's question from earlier (follow him btw he has great questions)

Reply
Cole12 ...
10/31/13 3:00 pm

No, that doesn't seem fair.

Mattwall1
10/31/13 3:00 pm

Just the knew that sent the pics then?

Cole12 ...
10/31/13 3:00 pm

Also, I saw you got accepted to a college. Congrats! What school?

Mattwall1
10/31/13 3:01 pm

Thanks. Kansas state.

skinner Wisconsin
10/31/13 3:01 pm

The guys would also get charged with production of child pornography.

skinner Wisconsin
10/31/13 3:05 pm

Do you know what you're going to do after?

Mattwall1
10/31/13 3:07 pm

My guess is either think tank or entering politics. I'm including grad school so yes I'd probably do that as well

Zod Above Pugetropolis
10/31/13 3:48 pm

Congrats Matt. I've had some mighty big fun in Manhattan. You'll enjoy it!

Mattwall1
10/31/13 3:50 pm

Thanks. Any tips about loving in Kansas? You know besides not saying I'm a democrat

Zod Above Pugetropolis
10/31/13 3:53 pm

Backwards as it seems today, East Kansas was big into the Freethought movement back in the old days, and Lawrence is still one of the most fun and liberal towns in the midworst. The weather sucks, but there's a lot to do in the greater Topeka area.

Mattwall1
10/31/13 3:54 pm

True. Ok thanks zod!

SmileyMoM Lab Rat Vampire
10/31/13 5:01 pm

Congrats Matt on going to K State! Don't spend too much time in Aggieville. And the weather in Kansas is great. We have it all. Just wait a day or two for it to change.