Show of HandsShow of Hands

mark4 November 7th, 2025 2:28pm

Between thinking and feeling, which should hold primacy?

16 Liked

Comments: Add Comment

pipishere Gocked and Evil
Today: 8:50 am

It depends what you're doing. If you're trying to fix a machine, thoughts are probably gonna be more useful than feelings. But in deciding what politics to hold and how society should be organized, thoughts are absolutely useless without consideration of feelings, as feelings are the whole experience of life.

Reply
mark4
Today: 8:56 am

And there’s your problem.

historylover Navy Seawolves
Today: 8:15 am

Thinking, but oh how those feelings try to control us sometimes. Feelings are especially hard to conquer when combined with strong memories.

Reply
persuader
Nov 07, 8:54 pm

Both the heart and the mind are important in learning and knowing truth, in receiving revelation from God.

tidford My little piece of heaven
Nov 07, 8:18 pm

I would not want to live an existence without feelings - just a thinking machine, but thinking must always be the dominant driver.

Reply
mark4
Today: 6:40 am

We agree.

Liberty 4,032,064
Nov 07, 4:59 pm

Thinking. Feelings are deceptive and mostly just an irrelevant hindrance.

Reply
vitriol
Nov 07, 6:51 pm

Then again, AI is getting much better than humans at the former, while not making much progress at the latter.

LibertarianB0b Christian Libertarian
Nov 07, 11:01 pm

I think it's a balancing act and if you depend solely on thinking because emotions can be deceptive you're ignoring that thinking can be deceptive if emotions aren't a portion of your thought process.

vitriol
Today: 6:20 am

I got to agree with Bob. Pushed to the extreme, an excellent thinker entirely deprived of emotions is also commonly known as a psychopath.

pipishere Gocked and Evil
Today: 8:54 am

Very unusual for me, but I completely agree with Bob's statement as well. Thinking without considering feelings leads to a cold, robotic existence with no meaning. You need feelings to decide which thoughts to follow. Even something as simple as choosing to eat only makes logical sense because of one's feelings about health and starvation.

bringstheeagle Colorado
Nov 07, 4:18 pm

I chose “thinking,” but honestly both are essential. Feelings and emotions can deepen and guide our reasoning — they’re part of what makes decisions human. Dr. Spock and Data are fun ideals, but they’re imaginary outliers. The rest of us have emotions… unless we’re sociopaths. 😁

Reply
pipishere Gocked and Evil
Today: 9:01 am

I really love Data as a character in part because of his character arc directly dealing with this topic. He is primarily designed to think logically, but is constantly seeking feelings to guide those thoughts. Definitely my favourite character in TNG, might be my favourite in the whole franchise. But I also love Janeway and Tuvok and the doctor in Voyager. I think Voyager is my favourite series of star trek.

pipishere Gocked and Evil
Today: 9:06 am

I also love Tilly and Saru from Discovery, but I dont like the path that series takes with the Burn, it feels inappropriately grimdark for my beloved spacefaring socialist utopian show.

CudOfCow Oregon
Nov 07, 3:07 pm

Thinking uses your brain. Feeling is caused by hormones affecting your brain. I'm going with thinking.

Reply
4JC Christian Pastors Wife
Nov 07, 12:38 pm

It depends on what you’re talking about. For many things, they work hand in hand. For example, we can think when studying the Bible, and feel the love of God and the leading of the Holy Spirit.

As to marital love, you often lose the feelings that you once had, but if you make a conscious effort to show love, those feelings can return.

Reply
mark4
Nov 07, 12:19 pm

Wow! Nonthinkum Dominum.

You’ll have to explain that one to me.

DJ13
Nov 07, 7:39 am

I feel that the answer is thinking....

Reply
martyinca California
Nov 07, 8:08 am

🤣🤣🤣
Many ( especially on the left) agree with you DJ.

mark4
Nov 07, 8:15 am

They only feel they do.

DJ13
Nov 07, 8:25 am

So, you're saying my feeling is wrong. Thinking isn't the right answer....hmmm...lol

DJ13
Nov 07, 8:30 am

Thinking and feelings work together in a continuous cycle, where thoughts can trigger feelings, and feelings can influence your thoughts. This connection is central to how we experience and interpret situations. For example, a negative thought can lead to distressing emotions, which in turn can lead to behaviors that reinforce the original thought.

mark4
Nov 07, 12:24 pm

Cap'n obvious.

You’ve told us what you feel. That carries some information. I think we’d get more from what you think, thus the question.

DJ13
Nov 07, 12:45 pm

I explained my thoughts. If you're having trouble reading or comprehending, I can't help you...

bringstheeagle Colorado
Nov 07, 4:31 pm

Good answer DJ

DJ13
Nov 07, 5:28 pm

Thank you...

pipishere Gocked and Evil
Today: 9:11 am

Mark, I'm not sure you're catching the point. Those feelings and thoughts are intertwined. One cannot exist meaningfully without the other. They told us what they feel as well as what they think because if and about those feelings.