Show of HandsShow of Hands

Nikc October 20th, 2013 12:53am

Do you believe that the rich should truly pay more than the middle class in order to create more government revenue?

7 Liked

Comments: Add Comment

TierasPet
10/19/13 7:35 pm

The government definition of rich is not realistic so no I don't think they should pay more.

BusinessJustin Tamriel
10/19/13 6:08 pm

I concede that it's almost socialist in nature, but the rates aren't high enough for full redistribution. I don't see a problem paying a higher percentage as you make more money, within reason.

skinner Wisconsin
10/19/13 6:01 pm

More money? Yes.
Greater percentage? No.

Reply
MJSeals J.D.
10/19/13 5:55 pm

They do pay more on a flat tax rate. I'm fine with that

BusinessJustin Tamriel
10/19/13 6:06 pm

On a flat tax they'd get quite the tax break, while the rest of us would pay more.

MJSeals J.D.
10/19/13 6:09 pm

Not really 10% flat tax will effect everyone by 10% the rich pay more and the poor pay less

BusinessJustin Tamriel
10/19/13 6:14 pm

45% of Americans currently pay no taxes. I'm in the 65th percentile of income and pay 6.7%. The very wealthy pay the overwhelming majority of all taxes paid. If everyone suddenly paid 10%, do you think it would really have that effect?

asia
10/19/13 7:45 pm

@justrich...I'm guessing that you refer only to federal income tax. Everyone pays some tax...whether sales tax, gasoline tax, property tax (directly or indirectly), state income tax, social security and Medicare taxes...the list goes on.

BusinessJustin Tamriel
10/19/13 7:57 pm

Yes, I refer only to federal income tax. Still a big advantage.

asia
10/19/13 8:54 pm

So your post was misleading if you were referring to fed inc tax only. And that's a big part of the flaw in the conservative argument that such a high percent pay no tax...it's an outright lie.

BusinessJustin Tamriel
10/19/13 8:58 pm

It's not a lie nor misleading. Sure, they pay these other taxes, but imagine if they were suddenly subjected to a 10% flat tax. Would that not cripple the poor further? And would the rich not suddenly be getting a tax break?

BusinessJustin Tamriel
10/19/13 8:59 pm

That stat also serves to illustrate a very valid point: that the overwhelming majority of our taxes are paid by a small fraction of the population. To equalize that with a flat or fair tax would only make income inequality worse.

asia
10/19/13 9:16 pm

But you are still wrong. If you are just talking about federal tax...then say so. Don't make these statements about how few people pay taxes...when it is wrong. Just say so many % do not pay FEDERAL income tax. What's so hard about that?

BusinessJustin Tamriel
10/19/13 9:44 pm

Really? Are you arguing the semantics? Sure, 45% of Americans pay no federal income taxes, but they also pay little or no state income taxes, less property taxes, and less sales taxes. The only thing that's steady are FICA taxes.

BusinessJustin Tamriel
10/19/13 9:47 pm

They pay substantially less taxes than average and the point still remains: flat or fair tax will shift the tax burden and only exacerbate income inequality. What's your solution?

Jack14 Massachusetts
10/19/13 5:55 pm

More money or more percentage?

Reply
Nikc
10/19/13 5:57 pm

This user is currently being ignored