Show of HandsShow of Hands

RepMorris October 13th, 2013 10:55pm

Virtual Congress Vote. This bill is brought to the floor by Congressman NathanE (R) of Pennsylvania. It is hereby illegal to use cell phones while operating motor vehicles.

24 Liked

Comments: Add Comment

pinkyusuck The Carribean. I wish.
10/14/13 9:56 pm

That's stupid. Do you know how much gets done via cell phones on the road?

ModerateGOP26 Maine
10/14/13 5:24 pm

I don't like the idea that you can regulate that heavily what one can do in his or her private property. I get the moral dilemma that it endangers others, but the "texter" will be found liable anyway.

Reply
zman117 Ohio
10/14/13 10:36 pm

This only has 46% approval!!!

RepMorris Pennsylvania
10/15/13 1:34 am

I think a new handful of votes just came along recently and changed it.

RepMorris Pennsylvania
10/15/13 4:12 am

I will consult with the President to decide what to do with this bill.

PartyFree Nowhere in Particular
10/13/13 9:17 pm

Nay. There are already "failure to perform the duties of a driver" laws in every state, under which cell phone use leading to an accident would be covered. Additional legislation is unnecessary.

Reply
skinner Wisconsin
10/13/13 7:05 pm

Yay, it kills people this is common sense legislation

skinner Wisconsin
10/13/13 7:08 pm

Nay, this legislation must be passed by state governments as it is beyond the authority of the federal government.

zman117 Ohio
10/13/13 6:51 pm

I would like to know where are the people claiming for state's rights?

If those same people don't call for it hear, then I don't see how that doesn't prove once in for all it is just partisan.

Reply
skinner Wisconsin
10/13/13 7:07 pm

Good point I'm changing my vote

MisterE Conservistan
10/13/13 6:33 pm

1) It should be up to the states.
2) It's way too broad.
3) it would be ridiculously hard to enforce.

Reply
kateXcore Dark side of the moon
10/13/13 6:31 pm

There is no reason for this unjust law! Don't tell me what to do! I can use my phone without harming anyone, and I have for like 10 years. Just because someone can't drive while doing it, doesn't mean all of us can't, and this bill doesn't address...

Reply
kateXcore Dark side of the moon
10/13/13 6:31 pm

Any other forms of driving distractions. This is a strong NAY! I live by the NAP.

zman117 Ohio
10/13/13 5:30 pm

Folks, I know this is only for good reasons. But it is simply not plausible.

Honestly, do you truly realize the full impact of it? Do you realize how many people need to receive calls while driving? Even for job purposes?

Reply
Mattwall1
10/13/13 5:31 pm

Yeah I switched back to no after seeing this

zman117 Ohio
10/13/13 5:32 pm

I mean seriously, do I have to spell it out for people? Think

Mattwall1
10/13/13 5:33 pm

I mean what if it's an emergency, and you can't pull over? What do you do?

political Georgia
10/13/13 5:38 pm

Sorry, I must result to my "personal sin" of talking on the phone while driving, but my decision is based off of more than my personal choice. It is also based off of the logical reasons Zmann presented.

NateE Moderate Republican
10/13/13 6:10 pm

It's not worth wrecking over and making a different emergency over. People wreck all the time while talking on the phone and endanger themselves and the people riding with them

political Georgia
10/13/13 5:29 pm

Texting-Yes
Answering phone calls- No!

Reply
zman117 Ohio
10/13/13 5:29 pm

No!
I can not support this. Are we also going to make using the radio illegal? Or what about the biggest one, eating and driving? That is surely distracting

Reply
political Georgia
10/13/13 5:29 pm

Wow! Zmann, I actually agree with you.

NateE Moderate Republican
10/13/13 6:17 pm

Actually in pa if you are eating and wreck you will be charged with wreck less driving and yes it is dangerous to eat, but the reason I bring up phones over eating is I have been called to about 10x more wrecks because of people on their phones than

political Georgia
10/13/13 6:20 pm

Same principle! This is like the gun issue. There comes a point where you find out that people are the problem not the item.

TomLaney1 Jesus is Lord
10/13/13 4:57 pm

I propose an amendment to change "while operating motor vehicles" to "while operating a moving vehicle." This would clear up two things - first, making a cell call on the shoulder of a highway in a parked but running car would thus

Reply
TomLaney1 Jesus is Lord
10/13/13 4:59 pm

not be prohibited, and second, this would cover airplanes, subway trains, school buses, tour buses, and other forms of multi-passenger public conveyances.

NateE Moderate Republican
10/13/13 5:02 pm

But are you actually operating the car while it's parked and running or a passenger on an airplane?

TomLaney1 Jesus is Lord
10/13/13 5:06 pm

Technically, you are facilitating the continued operation of the internal combustion engine and electrical systems by not turning the car off.

RepMorris Pennsylvania
10/13/13 5:16 pm

NathanE, this amendment has officially been proposed. Is there any objection? (Reply "I object" or "no objection")

NateE Moderate Republican
10/13/13 5:18 pm

No objection, in fact, I support it fully

RepMorris Pennsylvania
10/13/13 5:20 pm

Tlaeny1, what is your political party for the record?

RepMorris Pennsylvania
10/13/13 5:40 pm

The Amendment shall be brought to the floor.

political Georgia
10/13/13 5:42 pm

I object due to the unconstitutionality of the law because of the first amendment.

political Georgia
10/13/13 5:42 pm

Oh! Let me look at the amendment to see if I uphold my objection.

political Georgia
10/13/13 6:12 pm

I remove my objection if Laney's amendment passes.

spicysteve M14D SBS
10/13/13 4:42 pm

I think Bluetooth calls should be allowed.

Reply
HickBoy43
10/13/13 4:11 pm

Damn someone is making a lot of bills, bit I won't bitch because I haven't seen one I didn't like. Just dont get out of hand with it, ok buddy?

Reply
TomM
10/13/13 4:00 pm

I'm happy the younger generations propose and support this. I see it almost daily and especially younger drives. Please be careful when you drive.

NateE Moderate Republican
10/13/13 3:59 pm

This bill hits VERY VERY close to home to me as a firefighter and I take it very personal. I've seen SO many good people hurt or killed because they were on their phones and the accidents wouldn't of happened otherwise. They endanger the people

Reply
Mattwall1
10/13/13 4:00 pm

Are you including phone calls? If so, what if they're on Bluetooth?

NateE Moderate Republican
10/13/13 4:01 pm

Around them and the people in the car with them. Ive seen this happen to too many people. If you HAVE to talk, pull over. It's not worth your life or killing someone else and having to live with that for the rest of your life

NateE Moderate Republican
10/13/13 4:02 pm

No phones at all! I'm sick of unwrapping cars from trees because of them. It happens all too much

Mattwall1
10/13/13 4:07 pm

Ok, I just wanted to check, although I'm worried if its an emergency call.

Mattwall1
10/13/13 4:40 pm

True, I'm just pointing out an issue. I still said yay, but I did want to check. There are still some issues, but I'll say yay

SFLiberal
10/13/13 3:58 pm

Do you have to be elected into the virtual congress?

Reply
Mattwall1
10/13/13 3:59 pm

As long as you follow speaker afly you're a member

SFLiberal
10/13/13 4:06 pm

In that case, may I suggest a bill?

Mattwall1
10/13/13 4:07 pm

Sure

SFLiberal
10/13/13 4:12 pm

The Universal Healthcare Act of 2013: repeals Obamacare, replaces it with a single-payer system(like Canada, Norway, etc), and all money spent by citizens on Obamacare will be refunded to them.

Mattwall1
10/13/13 4:13 pm

The congress repealed Obamacare a while ago. Do you have trepidhickory or afly's Skype?

RepMorris Pennsylvania
10/13/13 4:13 pm

Obamacare has already been repealed here a few months ago. What exactly would you like to replace it with?

RepMorris Pennsylvania
10/13/13 4:17 pm

Here, word your bill however you like so I can just copy and paste it. I'll try to introduce it as early as tonight.

SFLiberal
10/13/13 4:22 pm

The Universal Healthcare Act of 2013: A single-payer healthcare system is established in the United States and all money spent by citizens on Obamacare plans will be refunded.

Octopus
10/13/13 3:57 pm

Even for phone calls, not just texting? What if you have Bluetooth?