Show of HandsShow of Hands

Praetorianus November 17th, 2019 1:07am

Imagine the office of the President does not exist. The US is governed by Congress alone with the speaker of the house tentatively representing the country abroad. Would that work?

14 Liked

Comments: Add Comment

JPA1960 Illinois
11/17/19 7:12 am

So the Articles of Confederation again, basically? That didn’t work in the beginning, and definitely wouldn’t work now. Even with some changes.

Senate101 San Diego
11/17/19 12:53 am

Yes, just like it does in scores of countries around the world.

Reply
TomLaney1 Jesus is Lord
11/17/19 12:08 am

With the present Congress? No way in heck.

Reply
historyqueen
11/16/19 11:58 pm

No, especially if we voted in a know nothing, do nothing Congress like we have now.

Reply
skinner Jersey City
11/16/19 8:29 pm

If the Speaker of the House were also the commander-in-chief of the military, then I think it could work. At that point, the Speaker would just be the equivalent of a Prime Minister.

Reply
Praetorianus Fair enough.
11/16/19 8:32 pm

Probably more like the Queen of England, representing the country on state visits but no executive power.

Zfilakas Eleftheria i Thanatos
11/16/19 7:55 pm

That basically was what the government was under the Articles of Confederation. It didn’t work.

Reply
DonWichita Kansas
11/16/19 7:18 pm

As much as I dislike Executive Orders, this makes a good case for them.

Reply
DonWichita Kansas
11/16/19 7:27 pm

Why ?
Because waiting on congress to act we would all starve, be over run by the tiny nation of Grand Fenwick, become jobless, die of ill health or have to learn the Chinese language.

Bigray4 Read my eyes
11/16/19 6:52 pm

I could see the Demon🐀s making the country worse than the USSR or Hitlers Germany.

Reply
Praetorianus Fair enough.
11/16/19 7:06 pm

We now would get Pelosi as de facto head of state.

Malekithe Hades
11/16/19 6:43 pm

Why not the Senate

Reply
Praetorianus Fair enough.
11/16/19 7:05 pm

Congress means both, house and Senate.

Malekithe Hades
11/16/19 7:14 pm

Why not the Senate conduct foreign affairs instead of Speaker

Praetorianus Fair enough.
11/16/19 8:28 pm

I was thinking about state visits abroad to represent the US.
Do you want the whole Senate to fly to Paris or Moscow?

Malekithe Hades
11/16/19 8:41 pm

No. I don’t want anyone in Congress but if i had to choose I would go Senate majority leader over speaker

Malekithe Hades
11/16/19 8:41 pm

6 years term vs 2 year makes for more consistent policy

Praetorianus Fair enough.
11/16/19 9:32 pm

I have an ignorant question: who is currently more powerful or important, the speaker of the house or the Senate majority leader?

Malekithe Hades
11/17/19 5:58 am

Depends how you define it.
Speaker is 3rd in line of secession currently.

Malekithe Hades
11/17/19 5:59 am

That is irrelevant, in your hypothetical scenario

Malekithe Hades
11/17/19 6:02 am

I just asked why the Speaker over the senate majority leader.
I don’t think either would be effective

Ebola007 Florida
11/16/19 6:20 pm

That would be a nightmare.

Reply
Carolynn new jersey
11/16/19 6:17 pm

No, because we wouldn’t have the separation of powers to protect the people from a corrupt government.

Reply
SuperAgain They lie, Get Over It
11/16/19 7:21 pm

That unicorn wont hunt! The notion of a separation of powers (checks and balances) is now broken, having been corrupted by Party Politics... the President and the Senate are clearly colluding to allow the President to act above the law and Obstruct Justice. Our Founders did not envision Senators putting Party over People (i.e., their individual State constituencies).

SuperAgain They lie, Get Over It
11/16/19 7:28 pm

We now have our own Eastern-European style corrupt government under Trump’s thumb. He committed extortion with Ukraine, but he’s been getting away with it for years now. He uses extortion to keep all of the Republicans in Congress in his pocket. If this corruption isn’t put down decisively, our Country will only slip deeper into the hole we find ourselves in!

jgf I have a few questions
11/16/19 8:21 pm

👍☝️☝️☝️ agree