Show of HandsShow of Hands

Show Of Hands December 17th, 2012 12:00am

When they are known to differ on a particular issue, should members of Congress vote with the opinion of the majority of their constituents, or vote according to their own principles?

1 Liked

Comments: Add Comment

ag90 New Jersey
12/24/12 9:44 am

They should vote according to voters. They have a responsibility to represent the nation and put aside their own personal opinions.

Reply
justin1121
12/21/12 3:43 pm

Voters...why the fuck else would we have elections?

Reply
Threeper301 Gilbert, AZ
12/21/12 3:06 pm

Or, here's a radical idea...have them, AND We the People, READ the bills before voting on them!!! (referencing Obamacare)

micah535 Missouri
12/20/12 9:14 pm

However, they should be open-minded enough to listen to their constituents stories and needs, how those issues affect their constituents lives, be willing to evaluate how that affects their principles, and be willing to change their minds and evolve on an issue.

2ndafe Flat lands of Ohio
12/20/12 1:21 pm

The politicians are supposed to vote their principles, while taking input from the people. The people are supposed to elect leaders with principles. The people have failed many times.

Reply
NYevo NY
12/20/12 4:02 am

If you simply want the majority to get their way on legislation, then we don't need a Representative democracy at all. All we'd need is online voting. The only point to having Representatives is so that they will vote their conscious after examining an issue to an extent that most of us don't

Threeper301 Gilbert, AZ
12/19/12 9:59 pm

.....and the other problem is the compromise of those principles to appease the other side. I'm sorry, but appeasement is cowardice.

Reply
amistad Columbus, OH
12/19/12 9:19 pm

They should attempt to vote in a manner consistend with those they represent.

Reply
4yourhealth Washington
12/19/12 6:39 pm

Without principles you have noting! Goes back to that whole if your friend jumped off a cliff would you saying. Not using or teaching principals is why our country is in the trouble we're in.

Reply
Threeper301 Gilbert, AZ
12/19/12 2:40 pm

Because if the government were to really wait until EVERYBODY'S vote to be cast and counted on EVERY piece of legislation, sh!t would NEVER get done.

Reply
MrFred
12/19/12 2:16 pm

If they just vote for what we want why the hell even have a congress?

Reply
Threeper301 Gilbert, AZ
12/19/12 1:51 pm

.....and how can you tell if a lawyer/politician is lying??? THEIR LIPS ARE MOVING

Threeper301 Gilbert, AZ
12/19/12 1:50 pm

This country is SUPPOSED to be a Democratic REPUBLIC, meaning Elected Representatives that speak on behalf of the people. Unfortunately, Washington is run by politicians who were LAWYERS first.....

ladyniner81 Embrace your inner dork
12/19/12 11:21 am

I'd rather have a politician who voted because he/she truly believed in it, then because he/she was drawn in because of $$$$$$
and he/she would be voting for their constituents because he/she truly believed it right??

alex232 Pennsylvania
12/19/12 10:15 am

we voted the politicians in who share the principles of the majority. it should be one and the same for most issues hopefully.

Reply
dflem Arizona
12/19/12 7:48 am

Voters. You're there to represent the people not yourself

Reply
jamjay Atlanta, Ga
12/19/12 4:07 am

If they actually had any principles.......

swasden Springville, UT
12/18/12 11:46 pm

We elect them to keep us fro our own rash decisions. You vet their moral judgement during their elections, and then you let them Ollie their morals once they are there, if there is something major, and they are split, then vote with the majority opinion of your constituents, but only then.

Reply
peoplecure California
12/18/12 11:40 pm

Majority does not make things right. Otherwise slavery should have been legal.

Reply
ELATeacher
12/18/12 8:57 pm

I for one want a politician will moral principles not one who will simply do what ever it takes to get reelected (which is whatever he thinks most of his voters want).

Reply
TopsQueen Oregon Coast
12/18/12 8:33 pm

That's what I like about DeFazio he voted his conscious I'm not a tree hugger at all but I'd like him.

flyberg Northern Kentucky
12/18/12 8:23 pm

If they only voted by majority there would be no United States. Took some statesman voting against what their constituents wanted to get us going.

Reply
snuffulufugus Missouri
12/18/12 6:59 pm

I'm referring to republicans in this case

pinkyusuck The Carribean. I wish.
12/18/12 6:00 pm

Incorrect, constituents are all of those in a representative's district. Otherwise, we would have significant sections of the populace legally without representation. I add legally because it's already the de facto case in some areas (conservatives in California, for instance).

Reply
pinkyusuck The Carribean. I wish.
12/18/12 5:57 pm

They should represent their constituents in almost every instance. However, if it's something that's directly contrary to their principles, they should vote present.

Reply
JackTorS SOH Flounder
12/18/12 5:53 pm

The LAST place we want people thinking intelligently and independently is in Congress, God forbid.
Rather they act like lemmings for partisan's sake.

Reply
chile safer than congress
12/18/12 5:38 pm

I'm pretty sure members of Congress set aside their principles the moment they began to vote raises and long-term benefits for themselves. And then repeated the trend annually.

Reply
chemist2016
12/18/12 4:59 pm

I wish there was a neither choice I prefer them to use logical reasoning and intelligent choices not personal beliefs and party affiliations

Reply
nFavOfSecess Texas
12/18/12 4:41 pm

Constituents... duh.

We don't elect these people do just do things that benefit themselves.

Reply
fourwinds box of rain
12/18/12 4:03 pm

Politicians know what's best for the country? LOL at that. Yah, that's why we are in this terrible economy, because of the responsible decisions of those who supposedly represent us.

Reply
fourwinds box of rain
12/18/12 3:59 pm

They are a representation of the voice of the voters...hence the term "representative."

Reply
RedneckDriggers Confederacy
12/18/12 2:53 pm

Congressman should listen to the voters on certain situations, but he should also vote on his party principles

Reply
mjohn620
12/18/12 2:52 pm

That was my reasoning, too. I was surprised to see the poll results...

Reply
fara9977
12/18/12 2:44 pm

"Constituents" refers to the people who voted for the elected official, not necessarily the entire population of his/her district.

meeksb11
12/18/12 2:17 pm

They were voted in for their beliefs. If they vote in congress on someone else's principles, theyre just betraying the people who got them elected in the first place.

Reply
Jabes
12/18/12 1:31 pm

Just to say, a lot of that I Jay only shows the funny interviews where they give obviously wrong answers or get camera-shy. I have a friend that was interviewed, knew the more obvious ones and just admitted he didn't on the stranger questions, so of course wasn't shown.

satiricalnick meh
12/18/12 1:22 pm

George washington himself said to never form factions (political parties). Look how the democrats and the republicans divide us today, why does it have to be like this? We're a nation, we need to start acting the part.

Reply
satiricalnick meh
12/18/12 1:19 pm

I liked both your comments as encouragement.

Reply
satiricalnick meh
12/18/12 1:13 pm

They were voted in based on their principles, therefore they should vote based on their principles.

Reply
GrandmaALiCE
12/18/12 12:09 pm

Does EVERY comments section have to have an insult in it? It would be really nice, if we could simply debate, without insulting each other.

I say this as an independent, not aligned with either "side."

Reply
CommonCent
12/18/12 11:58 am

This won't work for liberals...they have no principles except spend other people's money while holding their hands out.
Pathetic

Reply
gonzoboy Arizona
12/18/12 10:52 am

@Okie67, Amen! So with you on this for a host of reasons, the influence (control?!) of lobbyists among them.

Reply
pcfz
12/18/12 10:45 am

So? That was over 200 years ago. Back then people they considered the stupidity of people by not allowing everyone to vote and by having the representatives do what they think was best FOR THE PEOPLE.

TempName14 Everywhere but nowhere
12/18/12 10:37 am

According to the writers of the constitution, you're wrong. I don't have the exact Federalist Paper citation to give you, but they're supposed to vote their own opinion. They're elected by the people on the basis that their values and principles generally align with the people's.

Reply