Show of HandsShow of Hands

MrsCrayonWax May 29th, 2018 4:59pm

You are in a public setting. You hear two people conversing in a foreign language. Is it reasonable or not reasonable to demand they speak English?

18 Liked

Comments: Add Comment

ladyniner81 I hate people
05/30/18 3:11 pm

Unless you're a waiter/waitress in a ethnic restaurant (and the menu isn't in English, so if I point to it and ask what's that? They can tell me) or a driver, they need to understand directions, otherwise who cares?

BigPhatPastor Jefferson Hills, PA
05/30/18 5:31 am

Why is it anyone else's business since they are talking to each other?

MrsCrayonWax
05/30/18 5:50 am

I agree. It seems if you’re not speaking the queen’s English these days, busy bodies will call ICE or border patrol on you even if you are an American citizen.

jlong105 Indiana
05/30/18 4:26 am

I believe people in the service industry should be required to speak the common language. Especially doctors and drivers. Food service I give a pass on as you can always point at the menu.

bluerum29 optimistic idealist
05/29/18 5:45 pm

Nothing wrong with expecting it. Outright demanding it is different.

SoCalGal
05/29/18 5:44 pm

Since I live in SoCal, I never know what language I will hear when I’m out in public....Spanish, Arabic, Chinese, Korean, Japanese, maybe English. Sigh

bartman71 USW
05/30/18 12:08 am

I remember my first time in Vegas. Standing in line at a breakfast bar. There was probably 5-6 different languages being spoken. I thought it was awesome.

Zod Above Pugetropolis
05/29/18 3:16 pm

Unreasonable and totally asinine in every possible context and any imaginable situation. It’s basically saying, "I'm too lazy or stupid to learn your language, but my nosiness demands I hear and understand your every word, so speak English, and speak up."

Reply
MrsCrayonWax
05/29/18 3:29 pm

Or I’m thinking more along the lines of that pseudo chest puffing better speak the language or else type of scenario.

Xemanis Neutral Good
05/29/18 2:38 pm

Maybe not to each other, but if you work as a waiter in an American restaraunt for example then you definitely should know English

Xemanis Neutral Good
05/29/18 2:38 pm

I use this example because it's a HUGE problem where I live

MrsCrayonWax
05/29/18 3:28 pm

I can see that being a problem.

jlong105 Indiana
05/30/18 4:26 am

No problem with it if I go to an ethnic restaurant.

Xemanis Neutral Good
05/30/18 9:34 am

It's actually a major problem seeing as how they don't know English and can't understand you.

Xemanis Neutral Good
05/30/18 9:35 am

Or you might know a foreign language, but the point is that you can't expect to go to a foreign country and have everyone know your language

jlong105 Indiana
05/30/18 9:42 am

At a restaurant I just point at the menu. Now when I get a foreign Uber driver that doesn’t follow the GPS, I want to be able to discuss it.

jlong105 Indiana
05/30/18 9:43 am

I order my ethnic foods very plain. I rarely have restaurants deviate from their preparations.

Xemanis Neutral Good
05/30/18 9:53 am

I can do pronunciation just fine so I don't really need to point, but if the menu is in spanish too it's even worse.

If I were on my own and walked into a restaraunt where the menu was in all Spanish I'd probably leave. On the border there are a ton of Mexican restsraunts and the issue above is extremely common

jlong105 Indiana
05/30/18 9:55 am

I love those places! I have been fed by Uncle Sam for enough years to be willing to take a chance on what I order.

Xemanis Neutral Good
05/30/18 9:58 am

I've done that and it was a big mistake lol

jlong105 Indiana
05/30/18 9:59 am

Sometimes. But it is one meal and there will be thousands more.

Xemanis Neutral Good
05/30/18 10:36 am

Wish I had that kinda money to throw around

RussianThunder Russia and USA
05/29/18 2:00 pm

Not reasonable.

However, in public we speak English or sign language. People do not like to hear a foreign language. It makes people think they are being talked about.

So, it’s rude to ask but it’s also somewhat rude, if you speak English, to not do so in public.

TheMadScientist the mad laboratory
05/29/18 1:51 pm

Actually, I insist they speak Sohandeese. It sounds more like “wah wah wah” than whatever they’re speaking. If they refuse or look at me funny >BAM< natural selection.

xxxceo Still Deplorable
05/29/18 1:12 pm

Not if here talking to each other. Even if they’re speaking to me I wouldn’t require it. I wouldn’t understand them but I’m not the “speak English or leave type”.
If it was a business I may not go there simply because I couldn’t understand them.

snagglepuss Story Time
05/29/18 12:20 pm

America is the land of freedom. Freedom of speech!

Reply
ctskapski NB MD
05/29/18 12:17 pm

I would say no. It is not reasonable to dictate how one people holds a private conversation with another person who is not you.

CrzyChica
05/29/18 11:27 am

The majority of the world’s people speak more than one language. Americans are some of the few who seem to think people have to speak English at all times. By all means, if living in a country, learn the language as best as you can. But if you are talking to someone who speaks a common language or your native language, it’s nobody else’s business that you do.

Reply
MrsCrayonWax
05/29/18 10:46 am

Agreed. Inspired by the Gary and Shannon show on KFI. They did a story about this. Couldn’t find a link.

STONEYTJONES Indiana
05/29/18 10:41 am

If they aren’t talking to you, no.

Reply
lcamino Florida
05/29/18 10:32 am

That’s fine if they are speaking to each other. You will have a hard time communicating with them, though, unless you speak a common language.

orgblu10 Shamerica
05/29/18 10:26 am

To me, it's about communication, conveying your intended message accurately to the receiver. If they're more comfortable doing that in another language, so be it. I live in a city that is 76% Hispanic. By all means, learn English. But everyone is at different stages of progress toward that goal, and I accept that.

Reply
PrincessMelody Libertarian Left
05/29/18 10:12 am

No. They may be more comfortable speaking in their native language, or they might still be learning English and aren't that good at it yet.

Reply
Caseyh13 USA
05/29/18 10:01 am

People that would do that are the same type that would say, “This is America! Speak American!” 😂😂

Reply
CrzyChica
05/29/18 11:27 am

A lot of “foreigners” speak better English than Americans do.