Show of HandsShow of Hands

Comments: Add Comment

pinkiron
03/15/13 12:29 am

I can't figure out the whole treadmill thing ... So elliptical it is!!

MickieLauren
03/14/13 8:41 am

But aren't you doing the same thing? This can go on and on, but in the end, indeed, we are both wasting our time.

pirates765
03/13/13 8:54 pm

I prefer you go outside and walk or run. Or lift weights. The only energy expelled while working out should be your own, No electricity required.

pinkiron
03/15/13 9:08 am

Not so easy when you live in a state that has temperatures as high as the lowest setting of my OVEN!!

susanr Colorado
03/16/13 6:24 pm

That's why I used to have a non-electrical treadmill. Figured if I wasn't powering it myself, what good was it.

Note I said "used to have."

shebaondegy1
03/13/13 3:09 pm

I prefer the treadmill because you aren't constantly bouncing up and down. Normally I watch tv and power-walk and run during the commercials. This I do this for long periods of time and work off a good amount of calories.

cairochris
03/13/13 9:46 am

My sports psych professor was not a fan of the elliptical and made it clear when we talked about exercise & muscle physiology. The major drawback to it is that it doesn't focus on any muscle group. So it's hard to build muscle from it...Treadmill is far more effective in that respect.

Reply
cairochris
03/13/13 9:48 am

Elliptical is good at burning calories while you're using it, but that's about it. Machines that actually target muscles and build muscle lead to burning calories even when you are not working out (since muscle cells consume more calories than other cells, even in a resting state).

tchance2 32218
03/13/13 4:41 am

Treadmill: I feel more in my current state. I keep making money because I'm capable, government keeps taking it away and giving it to people I've never seen and I'm in the same position. And if I stop making money I have no clue what paperwork to file so I would fall flat on my face.

chivalry74
03/13/13 3:09 am

So I like the elliptical and my wife likes the treadmill. By the way, those treadmills with the elliptical bars, uh... not the same as the real deal.

kaik12 Twin Cities, MN
03/12/13 11:42 pm

I prefer ellipticals. Running on a treadmill and on the ground are too hard on a lot of my joints. The less impact the better. Sadly, I'm only 19. It'll only go downhill from here.

Reply
CarrieMarie Mad Science Crew
03/12/13 10:12 pm

It's easier to go backwards and work different muscles on an elliptical

susanr Colorado
03/12/13 9:36 pm

Um... Swimming pool? That's where I'd rather be, but of the other two, I'm trying to learn to love the elliptical. Kinda tired of the treadmill.

birdman007
03/12/13 8:49 pm

Neither. I prefer my recliner:)

Reply
dabrat East Coast
03/12/13 8:02 pm

I have both but prefer the treadmill

mherclif Ann Arbor, MI
03/12/13 7:54 pm

Most definitely elliptical. Not only do you get a better workout by burning more calories quickly, but the treadmill hurts my feet so bad!

skschroen always at school
03/12/13 7:53 pm

I hate treadmills- they just bother me. But personally i really like neither- i prefer an ergo machine

Mable
03/12/13 7:40 pm

Neither. Indoor cycling/spinning all the way! It's the most efficient and fun form of cardio I have ever tried.

mikz
03/12/13 6:55 pm

Treadmill makes my kneecaps hurt.

bchrome
03/12/13 6:29 pm

Huh, I just noticed, every state that was part of the original "Louisiana purchase", prefers ellipticals.

skschroen always at school
03/12/13 7:54 pm

That is really strange- but in modern day its only by chance with so much travel

14573 Scary Numbers
03/12/13 6:25 pm

Treadmill. Every time I try to get on an elliptical I end up putting both my feet in one slot and trying to get a circle going.

Reply
seahawk17
03/12/13 9:47 pm

I do the exact freaking thing! Until a couple of years ago when I rolled my ankle doing that.

Scoutless
03/12/13 5:59 pm

All the treadmills at the gym have tvs on them... So IF you're making me choose, I might as well not be bored

Reply
hichamELboss Boston
03/12/13 5:31 pm

I hate treadmills with a passion. Trails, roads...anything outdoors is where it's at.

Reply
latebird SOH Bunker
03/12/13 5:18 pm

Treadmills are more fun to slide on! Turn that baby up to 11 mph and then sit on it, and that is how I made a 2 foot hole in my basement wall 10 years ago

skschroen always at school
03/12/13 7:56 pm

. . . And your proud of that? Was it some sort of milestone for you?

CharlotteMassacare
03/12/13 4:11 pm

If the treadmill doesn't move uphill/downhill or something other then just go then elliptical all the way

Reply
lightsabr2 The Big Sky
03/12/13 4:06 pm

If I'm going to run, I'll run on the track. I use the machine when I want to work out, but I want to watch Netflix at the same time.

seahawk17
03/12/13 4:02 pm

Why not neither?
*mexican celebration music*

Reply
mementomori16
03/12/13 3:12 pm

Elliptical. I can do what a treadmill offers by walking or running on my own.

Reply
Futurama St. Thomas Estate Fortuna
03/12/13 2:26 pm

Run in a straight line going nowhere. No thanks. I'd rather do the elliptical. It's like skiing indoors.

Reply
skschroen always at school
03/12/13 7:57 pm

How is it like skiing? XC skiing maybe but not downhill.... I get wht you mean though its better than a treadmill and i live skiing

Happy Hong Kong
03/12/13 2:24 pm

I've had very bad luck with treadmills.

Mable
03/12/13 7:42 pm

Ha, meaning not achieving desired results or injury or...??

boxofdemons Marshfield MA
03/12/13 2:21 pm

If you use an elliptical you legitimately grow a vagina.

Reply
Futurama St. Thomas Estate Fortuna
03/12/13 2:26 pm

Yeah now I have two.

Itabliss Hello
03/12/13 2:49 pm

Are you implying that there is something wrong with having a vagina?

Zod Above Pugetropolis
03/12/13 4:42 pm

Having one of those I didn't have to share with somebody else would have saved me a whole lot of trouble over the years.

patrioticteen
03/12/13 7:30 pm

Mine hasn't grown yet I guess.

moonshot More often I know nothing
03/12/13 2:08 pm

Bowflex Treadclimber. It's the best of both in one machine. We have one and love it!

Mable
03/12/13 7:45 pm

I bought one of those about two years ago. It was a piece of shit and I returned it within 4 weeks. The belts would get too tight and stick after like 2 uses. I was so disappointed! Glad to hear you like yours though!

DavesNotHere where am I
03/12/13 2:03 pm

Both are great for cardiovascular exercises and both make me realize how out of shape I am.

Reply
lilandyben
03/12/13 1:32 pm

I lost all trust in the treadmill when it snuck that Lego on it. Good thing I was wearing shoes...

Reply
KudosToYou California
03/12/13 1:03 pm

For me and a bad ankle, less impact the better.

readhp1008 Hogwarts
03/12/13 12:36 pm

Really? I can't do treadmills. I run at an unsteady pace, so I'm always afraid I'll fly off.

Reply
JollyMan93 Big Sky Guy
03/12/13 12:11 pm

There are times when I run that my knees hurt bad either from poor stretching or just because...the elliptical gives me the opportunity to run and tone my body more without my knees hurting. If I'm not running outside, I'm running on an elliptical inside!

Reply
Arnae9
03/12/13 12:01 pm

The elliptical kills my knees. I have no idea why. You would think the opposite.

JollyMan93 Big Sky Guy
03/12/13 12:09 pm

That should be the opposite lol

cyanospool The Deep North
03/12/13 2:02 pm

Same. I have really long legs though, so they can't fully extend when I run on one.

rebelfury
03/12/13 11:43 am

I'm offended, rolling out of bed isn't considered in this poll :)

I prefer the low impact of an elliptical trainer after years of abuse (training).

Reply
line39
03/12/13 11:05 am

I like both in the winter when it's too cold or snowy outside, but as a runner, I prefer the treadmill.

gonzoboy Arizona
03/12/13 10:58 am

This may be off on a little tangent, but has anyone used a tread-climber? If so, how is it better/worse than a treadmill?

singkitty In the cloud
03/12/13 2:35 pm

I have. They had one at my gym. You can't actually run on it. I believe the max speed was 4 mph. I also don't think it burns that many calories. I am not a fan.

singkitty In the cloud
03/12/13 2:35 pm

I have. They had one at my gym. You can't actually run on it. I believe the max speed was 4 mph. I also don't think it burns that many calories. I am not a fan.

Mable
03/12/13 7:46 pm

couple of comments above on this too

lisalashe
03/12/13 10:54 am

I use both but I think I work harder on the treadmill.

TiltonAllStarz Outside Ur Comfort Zone
03/12/13 11:00 am

All the extra impact makes it feel that way, but you burn the same amount of calories on both.

mama3
03/12/13 10:49 am

I prefer running outside but if indoors, I like the treadmill better.

EnragedPirate
03/12/13 10:46 am

I feel like the elliptical just isn't as difficult as running on the treadmill, which itself doesn't feel as difficult as running outside, so I always grab a treadmill. I also wonder if the calories the elliptical gives can really be accurate... It seems far too easy to burn them. Does anyone know?

Reply
TiltonAllStarz Outside Ur Comfort Zone
03/12/13 11:03 am

It really is accurate.
The added impact of a treadmill, makes it feel like you worked harder

EnragedPirate
03/12/13 12:13 pm

It feels so much easier though, I usually don't get out of breath on the elliptical, is it just a difference in the way you're moving in each machine?

EnragedPirate
03/12/13 12:13 pm

I'd love to use the elliptical if its just as effective

TiltonAllStarz Outside Ur Comfort Zone
03/12/13 12:56 pm

Yes, you're using more muscles on the elliptical.
Double your workout times and holy crap, you'll start seeing muscle definition in your thighs, calfs and abs.
Your back will feel stronger.
All around better core.
It's quite nice.

BetaMax
03/12/13 10:43 am

I've never been able to use a treadmill from very long. I find the design to be very hard on my body, worse than just running outside. Between these two, I'll take the elliptical.

Reply
hippiedude fields of green
03/12/13 10:30 am

Elliptical, if I'm going to run, which I would rather do, its going to be outside on natural terrain.

Reply
timeout Boston Strong
03/12/13 10:23 am

How about if you just go outside and walk!

JackTorS Clap you stupid bastards
03/12/13 10:12 am

I love my treadmill. The handbars are just wide enough so I can hang my shirts on them.

Reply
hvp828 Carolina girl
03/12/13 10:08 am

I actually would have answered neither. I prefer running outside.

Reply