Show of HandsShow of Hands

Psychoanalysis December 2nd, 2017 11:30pm

Hypothetical: Donald Trump urges congress to declare war against North Korea citing “human rights violations and democracy”, this motion is passed after some deliberation. Do you support the move for military intervention into North Korea?

19 Liked

Comments: Add Comment

commonsense America isnt racist
12/03/17 5:24 pm

I’d want a stronger reason but yes, I will always support military action against dictators or govts that harm and oppress their people.

Harry3603 Tampa Bay Florida.
12/03/17 2:24 pm

No, not for those reasons, although since we only have s Truce in an unfinished war, the question is irrelevant.

geoag02 Dallas, TX
12/03/17 10:03 am

There would be no need. We are already at war with North Korea.

12/03/17 9:10 am

If we struck without them striking first then China would back NK. A war with China and NK would be an incredibly bloody and destructive war. So my answer is no.

Hogoke Constitution
12/03/17 1:33 am

They have threatened our allies numerous times, they literally launched missiles that landed off the coast of Japan. Not only that but they kill their own innocent citizens on a daily basis.

The weirdest thing about this whole mess is that if the US launched a ballistic missile at anything the whole world would be trying to kill us.

LeftLibertarian The Age of Outrage
12/03/17 1:06 am

Such a dreadful idea, I’d be lost for words if this was even legitimately considered.

bnnt Los Angeles
12/02/17 10:37 pm

Can’t even imagine how ugly of a war that could be.

NK knows they’re in a bad spot, but who knows what kind of hacking and dirty nukes they’ve been planning.

gluxford1 Arizona
12/02/17 7:22 pm

No. We have had enough wars already.

Domino3 Abolish the ATF
12/03/17 2:49 am

You were saying we should nuke them a few weeks ago..

gluxford1 Arizona
12/03/17 7:10 am

Only if we know for sure that they’re going to attack us.

gluxford1 Arizona
12/03/17 7:13 am

The reasons listed in the poll question are not good enough reasons to launch a nuke.

Advil sc
12/02/17 6:57 pm

I support military intervention if it is necessary for the safety of our allies and the United States 🇺🇸 of America.

Liberty 4,032,064
12/02/17 6:46 pm

No. That would be aggression unless they’ve done something first.

DoctorWasdarb Marxist Leninist Maoist
12/03/17 12:27 am

Huh. The only rightist to actually oppose American agression around the world.

Hogoke Constitution
12/03/17 1:34 am

Hmm how about the numerous missiles that landed off the coast of Japan.

DoctorWasdarb Marxist Leninist Maoist
12/03/17 1:36 am

You mean, missile tests that landed in the ocean?

xxxceo Nationalist
12/02/17 6:44 pm

Only if we run out of options. Imo, we should assassinate Little Kim and prop up the new guy with the understanding that he dismantles the nukes.

RedTerror Marxism Leninism Maoism
12/02/17 6:06 pm

Land war in Korea against China? Good luck

Praetorianus Fair enough.
12/02/17 6:11 pm

The Chinese army is huge but maybe overrated.
In 1980, they raided Vietnam as a "punishing action" (not sure for what).
They lost 80,000 men within a few days.

fmm Philadelphia suburb
12/02/17 5:57 pm

1. the war machine must be fed
2. Trump needs to create a new diversion

so ..... likely.

Malekithe Bedrock
12/02/17 5:54 pm

Ship been sailing for 24 years and has done sailed by

Alcerus fascist
12/02/17 5:47 pm

Negative. I think we'd tick off Russia if we did that. I think, if anything, we should go into NK with China and Russia if they're up for it. Definitely not go in by ourselves though. Not because we can't win, but because this would be a good chance to shale hands with our former adversaries

GlockMan1 Alabama
12/02/17 5:24 pm

We made the same mistake in Vietnam.

12/03/17 5:15 am

Agree and this is a good analogy. It's comparable in so many ways. Just a very scary thought.

Casper Deep inthe Heart ofTexas
12/02/17 5:08 pm

Hypothetical: a coup erupts within North Korea and requests our support.

Most likely we support them.
More likely we are them.
I wish we could trust ourselves.

popapop2 Ohio
12/02/17 4:57 pm

Yes. I think that we should strike them now before things go beyond the point of no return and either they go to war with us. Perhaps not likely, or we must forever accept a nuclear NK for the next 50 to 100 years or longer, putting East Asia in constant disarray and also have NO as a leech on the US and the world as they unstablize it. Perhaps it's time to finish what we tried to do in the Korean War which never officially ended, just a cease fire.

Also we should stop being naive and thinking that China will stop NK, and put a leash on them. Not going to happen.

Praetorianus Fair enough.
12/02/17 4:36 pm

Not an acceptable casus belli for me.
NK is a sovereign country.
I don't favor killing thousands to force them to treat their own better, overthrow has to come from within like in the Arab spring.

ComradeJames nationalism
12/02/17 5:57 pm

It wouldn't be to get them to treat their own better, or we'd have intervened decades ago. If we go to war with the DPRK now, it's solely due to the DPRK's nuclear arsenal and threat to US imperialism.

Praetorianus Fair enough.
12/02/17 6:03 pm

Yes but Trump would cite this as a reason, it "sells" better.