Show of HandsShow of Hands

RussianThunder November 8th, 2017 11:06pm

In this age where statues are taken down and schools renamed, why has no one stated the FBI building should be renamed? Hoover was a white supremacist who didn’t follow the law and thought the FBI was above it. Change the name?

11 Liked

Comments: Add Comment

martyt02
11/09/17 5:42 am

Your logic applies: “if one, why not the other”. I just disagree with changing names for those reasons.
Maybe it is good to to be reminded of J Edgar and his history. Doesn’t knowing the the good cause us to evaluate the bad?

RussianThunder Russia and USA
11/09/17 8:27 am

I would agree. I just wondered what others thought

Senate101 San Diego
11/08/17 8:03 pm

Sure, doesn't matter.

Reply
ctskapski x
11/08/17 8:03 pm

No, he started the FBI. It makes sense to be named after him.

I also think it's senseless to take down statues.

Reply
GlockMan1 Alabama
11/08/17 7:17 pm

Most statues that are being taken down are now in predominantly BLACK cities. Those statues were put up many years ago when those cities were predominantly WHITE. Why is everyone surprise that blacks want these gone and why are white cities not taking them and putting them up?

Reply
4boot LaTrineodeur, MN
11/08/17 6:48 pm

Yes, but won't happen because he was gay.

Reply
LibArtie SW Connecticut
11/08/17 5:59 pm

I’m OK with stripping the building of his name because he was a bad dude. That said, I’ve never heard that he was a white supremacist.

RussianThunder Russia and USA
11/08/17 7:04 pm

Apparently he was trying everything to stand up against the civil rights movements. Actually committing illegal acts to try to discredit black leaders to shut down race mixing.

LibArtie SW Connecticut
11/08/17 7:07 pm

Perhaps, but your use of the word “apparently” leads me to suspect you have uncertainty and no source.

RussianThunder Russia and USA
11/08/17 7:34 pm

Well, it was a documentary and calls made from LBJ to JEH and JEH to LBJ were unusual. The documentary listed all the things the FBI did. Had interviews with the FBI agents involved. I enjoy the documentaries but I’m not so familiar with American history to know if the documentarian had a hidden motive. LBJ certainly uses the N word but he worked for civil rights. To be honest, I had a hard time understanding anything that man said. It’s like Jeff Sessions, it’s hard to keep up.
So, yes, I am tempted to believe it based on the phone calls and interviews but it’s not a rock solid source by any stretch of the imagination. That’s why I used “apparently”.

LibArtie SW Connecticut
11/08/17 7:40 pm

Well explained! You’re basing your comments on a documentary whose credibility you’re uncertain of, but have confidence in, correct? Your concern for being accurate is laudable, especially here on SOH.πŸ‘

xxxceo Nationalist
11/08/17 5:46 pm

The left is in love with the FBI at the moment. Assume Trump is vindicated and the Feds go after Hillary, they’ll start hating the FBI again.

Reply
lcamino Florida and Georgia
11/08/17 5:24 pm

No, Hoover WAS the FBI !

Reply
RussianThunder Russia and USA
11/08/17 7:05 pm

That’s seems to be the problem actually

jztheman Connecticut
11/08/17 5:19 pm

Maybe rename after Theodore Roosevelt or Charles Bonaparte, the two people who can be given credit for the creation of the FBI.

Hyli
11/08/17 5:04 pm

Extremely false equivalency.

Reply
orgblu10 Shamerica
11/08/17 4:39 pm

Definitely. It's long overdue.

Reply
catpillow Florida West Coast
11/08/17 4:35 pm

No, when I think of the FBI, J. Edgar Hoover's name is the first name that comes to my mind. His name is synonymous with the FBI. I think it would be the same for most Americans.

Reply
geoag02 Dallas, TX
11/08/17 4:31 pm

He may have been a white supremacist, but that’s ok because he was also a democrat. Democrats don’t really have a problem with racism, they just use that as a generic insult against their political opponents to shut them up.

Reply
Sentinel Ya ie wa noh
11/08/17 4:26 pm

Yes..... "Fake Bureau of Investigation"..... McCabe, Mueller and Comey need to be prosecuted for complicity and espionage et. al.......

Reply
voc Hey
11/08/17 5:39 pm

Why? Comey maybe, or at least investigated, but why mueller? So far he’s just doing his job.

Sentinel Ya ie wa noh
11/08/17 5:50 pm

Mueller & Comey have a history going all the way back to Bush as Ashcroft......further, once Mueller took the hem, he should of reviewed everything Comey did in the previous investigation.....no way he did not have intimate knowledge of the higher level influence and coercion of Comey and McCabe.....

gluxford1 Arizona
11/08/17 4:10 pm

No statues should be taken down and no building should be renamed. I am opposed to erasing America's cultural and historical heritage.

Reply
gluxford1 Arizona
11/08/17 4:37 pm

πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡ΈπŸ‘πŸ»

doober72 Vidalia, Ga.
11/08/17 5:04 pm

Agreed Gluxford πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡Έ!

thatguy2 We tried to warn you
11/08/17 5:12 pm

This user is currently being ignored

4JC Christian Pastors Wife
11/08/17 5:33 pm

We combatted white surpemacy back in the 60’s, thatguy.

It does no one any good to whitewash history so we don’t learn from it.

I think we should build new statues next to the old ones, that are in honor of those fought slavery and fought for Civil Rights. Then, black families can. Bring their kids, show them both statues, learn from them for free, and EMPOWER their kids with the knowledge of how far they’ve come!

...

bower8899 ...
11/08/17 4:09 pm

Last time I visited dc I realized something.

They named the ugliest building in the city after one of the ugliest personalities! :P

Reply
Diogenes Not Biden It
11/08/17 4:08 pm

No. I don't subscribe to altering history so I can't condone your suggestion even though it makes sense.

Reply
thatguy2 We tried to warn you
11/08/17 5:13 pm

This user is currently being ignored

4JC Christian Pastors Wife
11/08/17 5:45 pm

Textbooks are revised, thatguy, all the time. Believe me, what they’re learning in school nowadays is NOT what I learned in school!

...

NathanBForrest Texas
11/08/17 5:48 pm

Implying leftists wouldn't start burning books.

Diogenes Not Biden It
11/08/17 5:49 pm

Until you fascist leftists burn the books and push your alternative history in the communist controlled schools. Hell, most people around don't remember a time before the US was sprinting towards globalism; hence, the rabid outcries when Trump changed the narratives that the MSM were feeding them.

4JC Christian Pastors Wife
11/08/17 6:01 pm

Yes, there is THAT, also, Nathan! After all, the censoring has already started.

A theater in Memphis is no longer showing “Gone with the Wind”, which is ironic since it’s the first movie in which a black woman won an Academy Award, for the part of Mammy.

Also, To Kill a Mockingbird is being censored in Mississippi!

So liberals are trying to wipe out ALL the pieces of art—movies, books, statues—that could actually teach about the bad side of our history—so that we don’t repeat the mistakes of the past.

I just read your comment, Dio. I don’t know enough about Nathan to know where he stands. Did I misread him? I thought he was saying that leftists will burn books to wipe out history just like they’re trying to do with other forms of art. Either way, I agree with what you’ve said, Dio.

...

...

NathanBForrest Texas
11/08/17 6:03 pm

4JC we've met before like 3 months ago (I went to bootcamp). I'm a Constitutionalist. Yes, that is exactly what I was saying.

4JC Christian Pastors Wife
11/08/17 6:38 pm

Oh, Good! Thanks, Nathan. I should’ve know with a name like that, you’d be on our side on this issue! Lol

4JC Christian Pastors Wife
11/08/17 6:40 pm

So you survived bootcamp. How was it? I know of guys that literally cried! Lol

We have a good many military friends and have lived near military bases, visited on post, sold Avon on post, drove a school bus on post, etc.

In fact, I drove a bus that stopped just outside the gates right after 9/11. It was a mess, since they locked down the gates.

...

NathanBForrest Texas
11/11/17 6:06 am

I had to watch suicidal recruits on fire watch.

4JC Christian Pastors Wife
11/11/17 11:04 am

Fire Watch? I’m sorry—-I don’t know what that means.

NathanBForrest Texas
11/11/17 11:07 am

A squadbay burned down once, killing everyone inside, so we now have a watch posted throughout the night to make sure there aren't any fires going on, among other things.

4JC Christian Pastors Wife
11/11/17 12:11 pm

Oh, wow! Are you saying that someone committed suicide by arson and killed other people in the process?

...

NathanBForrest Texas
11/11/17 12:14 pm

No, I'm saying a fire started by accident and killed everyone in the building.

4JC Christian Pastors Wife
11/11/17 12:21 pm

Oh, ok! You’re saying you had to watch suicidal recruits confused me. Sorry!