Show of HandsShow of Hands

737 November 8th, 2017 1:17am

Is a direct democracy a good idea? Please discuss your answer.

1 Liked

Comments: Add Comment

DoctorWasdarb Decolonize
11/07/17 10:39 pm

I prefer a more participatory democracy. Direct democracy is preferable to what we have now though.

Reply
737
11/07/17 8:44 pm

This is my first post so please feel free to give constructive criticism.

737
11/07/17 8:44 pm

This is my first post so please feel free to give constructive criticism.

PrinceOberyn Here I am Here I Remain
11/07/17 7:17 pm

If the hoi polloi were uniformly intellectual and informed. So, no.

They're idiots.

737
11/07/17 8:42 pm

Thanks for replying.

LeftLibertarian The Age of Outrage
11/07/17 6:28 pm

Yes, so much better than representative democracy in pretty much every way I can think of. Variants of it like direct consensus democracy are particularly good, and easily deal with most concerns brought up against it, not that they were even much of a concern to begin with, especially in comparison to representative democracy. For one particular example, the mob rule argument is silly given that mob mentality is much more strongly encouraged encouraged by hierarchical organizations.

Reply
737
11/07/17 6:41 pm

I can see your point, but think Bout it like Plato and Socrates. They were both very wary of a direct democracy because they thought they average man didn't think enough about his decision.

737
11/07/17 6:42 pm

I think representative democracies in the end would be better than direct a democracy.

LeftLibertarian The Age of Outrage
11/07/17 8:57 pm

The low education standards of the average person are a result of our education model which was derived from Prussian military rule. Johann Fichte, an advocate of the model, argued that schools aught to fashion the person, and fashion them in such a way that they simply cannot will otherwise then what you wish him to will. It intentionally crushes the critical capacities of the individual to create an obedient workforce. This education model also aught to be done away with in favor of a democratic model that expands the creative impulses of individual students. I think your concern is genuine, but honestly it appeals to a condition within our current system to justify itself.

737
11/08/17 6:06 am

I agree with you. A direct democracy would only work if the people were educated well enough, but the problem is people still aren't educated in diplomatics or the affairs of other nations so I still have to disagree. The question was would it work in our society.

737
11/07/17 6:23 pm

Large crowds make poor decisions, the average person is not wise enough to make these decisions, and it's too slow.

Reply