Show of HandsShow of Hands

Show Of Hands October 15th, 2012 12:00am

Should debate moderators try to enforce debate rules strictly, or be as flexible as possible as long as candidates are getting roughly equal time?

1 Liked

Comments: Add Comment

Alienmoose1 New York
10/19/12 10:42 am

Why on earth wouldn't you want the mod to fact check a candidate if they say something untrue? I'm not talking about Obama or Romney I mean you, an American. Isn't it in your best interest to hear the facts? I thought that's what journalism was all about...

leosummer Indiana
10/18/12 10:56 am

Moderating is like being a peer counselor for teenagers. No one listens and everyone is right.

cowboy Come on, man
10/18/12 5:53 am

How about they stop getting Liberal wackjobs that are Obama supporters? Obama has gotten more time and still lost with the "moderator" helping him.


10/17/12 11:25 pm

I wish they'd have a college debate coach moderate the debate instead of some political analyst or news person. Someone not publicly political should do it-- even someone like Ryan seacrest! It should be someone random with experience moderating a debate who isn't on the news


10/17/12 11:19 pm

Candy was a horrible moderator bc she overstepped her duties. You don't correct anyone! You just say things like "it's your turn" or "what is your response to __?" or "time is running out and we need to go to the next question." HELLO!! Debate 101- No input, corrections or help from the moderator!!!

andithinkthat Texas
10/17/12 11:56 am

I want to hear some of everything. If left to themselves, we would get nowhere.

kaik12 Twin Cities, MN
10/16/12 10:21 pm

I would rather have the debate go a bit longer than have the debators not be able to make main/final points. I watch the debates to learn about their views and policies, not to have it get cut off at the end.

DrReid Ever present.
10/16/12 6:40 pm

When the politicians are held accountable, republicans lose. No wonder they don't what any accountability.

Reply
Zod Above Pugetropolis
10/16/12 6:26 pm

Ask a question, as soon as the subject begins to drift, interrupt. Ask the question again, and if not answered directly and concisely, interrupt again, point and shout "Fail!", and move on to the next question. The rules are very simple. Follow them or leave as the loser.

Reply
ntvtxn62
10/16/12 5:30 pm

Enforcer is they're filer busting. Otherwise let them go after each other.

TopsQueen Oregon Coast
10/16/12 3:51 pm

The moderated is a demo.

Reply
not_even Boston, MA
10/16/12 3:03 pm

Keep it roughly equal. Some points they make need some time to explain.

Reply

10/16/12 1:55 pm

Interesting view from the sexes! The women say, "Keep to the facts and stay civil" And the men say, "You can get dirty, but don't go over the time limit!"

Reply
Ilovedutch
10/16/12 10:13 am

As much as I think the rules should be enforced as much as possible, I think it would totally jeopardize the point of the debate, because there are often situations in which a candidate must simply extend their time shortly to make a point.

ScrewU Gone
10/16/12 8:32 am

If it were up to me, they would have a yellow warning light in front of them for 10 seconds left and then the microphone would cut off.

Reply
tidford My little piece of heaven
10/16/12 7:14 am

The debate I've always wanted to see was one in which there would be no moderator. The candidates would simply take turns asking each other questions. How each candidates deported him/her self would teach us a lot!

Reply
tidford My little piece of heaven
10/16/12 7:05 am

The more power you give a biased person the more that bias can, and likely will be abused. Republicans view reporters as having a very strong bias towards Democrats. Given that view, Republicans quite naturally wish to minimize the bias. In tonight's debate count Candy's interruptions & challenges.

suppressedID Shut up man
10/16/12 6:35 am

Careful. If they start asking Romney math questions he's screwed. His plan to balance the budget doesn't hold up which is why he's afraid to give actual details. That job is harder than he makes it out to 47%.

yepnope Maryland
10/16/12 5:50 am

Fox News sheep...

Reply
kytoaltoky
10/16/12 5:12 am

Ooh, Sean Hannity and Ed Schultz co-moderating a debate held in a steel cage! Brought to you by Red Bull and Smirnoff! Of course, we'd need some stand-in candidates to make it interesting!

Reply
kytoaltoky
10/16/12 5:06 am

If that's sarcasm, it needs work!

Reply
gonzoboy Arizona
10/16/12 3:58 am

@Septer, Obama did attend Martha Raddatz wedding approx. 20 years ago. Then, shortly after Obama was sworn in, appointed her now ex-husband as the Chairman of the FCC.

Reply
honored
10/16/12 3:51 am

Sixpluvs, he was being sarcastic anyway

honored
10/16/12 3:51 am

Slxpluvs, don't think your smarter than everyone else. If you were living on welfare and wanted to keep living, and welfare was taken away, and no one is giving you a job, what do you do (you have no money) you steal of course.

Reply
gonzoboy Arizona
10/16/12 3:35 am

It'd be nice to make an informed comment here, but that's not likely. I've yet to see what a debate looks like when rules are actually applied, much less enforced. As a nod to novel concepts, I selected Enforcement. We're all familiar with meek timekeepers, so what have we to lose?

Reply
TheMadScientist the mad laboratory
10/16/12 3:30 am

Its their love of crime and wealth distribution that makes Democrats such well known as enforcers.

scottstots Georgia
10/16/12 12:52 am

Bill O would be awesome, and if was busy, Sean Hannity would be another great choice. Both impartial with the highest journalistic integrity. And not looking for govt. handouts

Reply
Doopy Remedial Americanism
10/16/12 12:18 am

I really don't get the party split, here. Anyone know why this is?

Doopy Remedial Americanism
10/16/12 12:17 am

Don't disregard that personality type, though. Most of history's greatest minds thought that way.

Drew41
10/15/12 10:57 pm

I want someone to drill them until they answer a question clearly. They just change the subject and bounce around the question! Bill O could handle the job!

Reply
wetheslaves Live each moment fully
10/15/12 10:51 pm

It would be nice to hear more variety not just their prepared responses and preach time. It would also be nice to see how they Handel being snubbed. We have to deal with not getting things the way we want them!

babyboomer1 The flatulance express
10/15/12 10:37 pm

Disregard of rules and limits are an indicator of a personality that feels they're above it. They apply to everyone else, not me.

Reply
Bolide
10/15/12 10:32 pm

They go over their time, cut their mic! Lol

Reply
lmurder MDK
10/15/12 10:18 pm

Radditz got worked over ad wasn't qualified for the job.

Reply
Christfollowr California
10/15/12 10:00 pm

The should be more strict otherwise you get what happened at the debate

Reply
Septer
10/15/12 9:43 pm

Wasn't Obama at her marriage or something? That might have to do with something.


10/15/12 9:40 pm

I think radditz was left of center (though hardly in the dem's corner) but many her interruptions of Ryan were poignant. I want to like Romney but I have no specific info. Right now I'm abstaining because I'd rather that than vote blind on a hope and a prayer. The mods need to ask for info

Reply
akgoat UniversityofAlaska
10/15/12 9:35 pm

For what its worth, I approve of the latest update(I also gave it the corresponding review update). Keep up the hard work Tony!

Reply

10/15/12 9:32 pm

@ Leo, not disagreeing. But how was the same body/facial/vocal language dignified for Ryan and weak for Obama. Not a dem btw, fiscally conservative, socially liberal (for civil rights only, and by civil I mean universal, not racial)

lmurder MDK
10/15/12 9:02 pm

Enforcer. Tom brokaw said it best.

suppressedID Shut up man
10/15/12 8:59 pm

Not me. My guy never loses. Even when he does.

Reply
suppressedID Shut up man
10/15/12 8:57 pm

Give them a whistle and a b&w striped shirt. They can call offsides, delay of game, and COMPLETE BS.

Reply
davidwhite1 Building it Bigger
10/15/12 8:51 pm

If the moderator becomes an enforcer it might make the candidates actually answer the questions rather than get into the all to often Banter of rehearsed talking points.

Reply
natedog1
10/15/12 8:48 pm

She picks what questions to ask from the audience

EarlyBird Portland
10/15/12 8:44 pm

And let's hope the moderator asks great questions!

Btw, anyone know where the questions come from?

Doopy Remedial Americanism
10/15/12 8:39 pm

If the candidates want flexible time regulations, they should make it clear in the debate rules. The moderator should then follow the debate rules. Because they're the rules! Duh.

If it pissed you off in the NFL, it should piss you off in the presidential debates.

Leo88 New Jersey
10/15/12 8:30 pm

Like Ryan said to Biden, the country will be better served if you stop interrupting and we each take a turn to speak. Ryan showed poise and spoke like a gentlemen.

Reply