Show of HandsShow of Hands

ShawPPM1214 August 9th, 2016 4:10am

Is it wrong for pastors and ministers to endorse candidates and legislation from their pulpits?

14 Liked

Comments: Add Comment

jvc1133 61535
08/10/16 12:48 pm

Not wrong, but I'll walk out. 😎

Reply
SamSoup Christian, voluntarist
08/10/16 9:19 am

Christians shouldn't have any part I the dealings of ruling over other men.

tech24073
08/09/16 11:18 pm

When they enter so blatantly into politics, yank the tax exemption. We have a pay to play system.

Reply
corino Utah
08/09/16 7:24 pm

Endorsing candidates or parties voids your non profit status. Advocating moral and political positions is your job (at least in Judeo-Christian tradition).

Reply
pietsch Another Adoring Fan
08/09/16 5:27 pm

It's not wrong. It's against the law. These two things don't always coincide.

Reply
ShawPPM1214 Washington
08/09/16 7:10 pm

Pastors endorse candidates all the time. They even appear on the news to talk about their candidates. How is it against the law?

theNobamist Silicon Valley
08/10/16 2:16 am

They're not at the pulpits when they're on the news. Except for Jackson and Sharpton-- the TV is their pulpit.

nsmith Suck on my freedom
08/09/16 2:35 pm

It was very wrong for the pope to do so.

tech24073
08/09/16 11:19 pm

To be fair, the pope also represents an independent country (right or wrong as that may be).

xzach next door to you
08/09/16 10:36 am

The influence a pastor or religious leader has over a congregation is tremendous and should not be abused. Political parties have built entire platforms on appealing to the religious right with little results in legislation and change. Pastors are getting filthy rich pointing their loyal flock in the direction of a particular party. Example Mike Huckabee making millions on Fox News and mega church preachers taking speaking engagements to promote a party while the flock delivers the vote only to be dismayed in the end with no results. Why do you think the religious right is supporting "Trump"? If he were of another party they would not give him the time of day. Their pastor said vote for him so now he's acceptable!

Reply
ConservativeCA Joe Biden is barely alive
08/09/16 3:24 pm

You don't seem to have a good understanding of priesthood, and are probably not a church going Christian. Priests and ministers live very meager lives, often in a small monastery on the grounds of their church. I don't think Mike Huckabee is an active preacher (if he ever was) and that certainly is not the case for 99% of preachers/priests.

xzach next door to you
08/10/16 7:43 am

I have a very good understanding of priesthood and preachers. I am also a practicing Christian. The question was related to the influence "some" not all preachers have on political elections. I pointed out the extreme cases, such as Mike Huckabee who has gone from the pulpit to Politics and uses his influence as a "religious leader" to push Christians to vote a certain way. He makes millions abusing this trust people have in him. There are also many cases of "Mega" church preachers who do the same for money. The average priest does not get into this practice, although many do influence there flock to vote a certain way.

ronderman North Carolina
08/09/16 9:44 am

It's dumb if them to do. I've been in churches all over this country and I have never attend a church that openly endorsed a candidate. Most churches (that I have attended) will speak on specific policies but will not endorse specific people.

Okie1967 Defend the Police
08/09/16 9:21 am

I don't see why it would be wrong. Every celebrity and other public figure does it.

Reply
thebarr
08/09/16 3:09 am

In general, yes, but they should be allowed to do it.

PamGH Washington
08/08/16 10:01 pm

If they do that's fine, but their nonprofit status should be revoked.

Reply
shoeless Texas
08/08/16 10:06 pm

I don't see the connection. I don't agree with everything my pastor says and I question and consider his views as a matter of course. If he spoke for or against a political candidate, that wouldn't change. More importantly, it wouldn't change my church being a non-profit organization. Want to remove non-profit from a group? Go after the NFL.

PamGH Washington
08/09/16 3:28 am

It's against the law. Tax Rules Forbid Churches From Endorsing Candidates, Will IRS Take Action? www.forbes.com/sites/peterjreilly/2015/09/20/tax-rules-forbid-churches-endorsing-candidates/#7eb76496412f

shoeless Texas
08/09/16 5:28 am

I know it is against the law. I think it's an outdated law now. There are a number of things that are against the law, but we seem to allow or accept. Illegal immigration is against the law. Marijuana use, possession,etc., is against federal law, but we aren't locking up Colorado...

shoeless Texas
08/09/16 5:29 am

Pam - when you want to show a law, I'd suggest quoting the actual law rather than a Forbes article.

nekmor Round Rock TX
08/09/16 6:18 am

I believe the question was for an opinion as to whether was wrong or not. Not as to whether IRS had ruled against it.

If we were willing to except all existing rules and laws as being right slavery would've never been abolished in women still would not have the right to vote.

rons on top of the world MA
08/09/16 11:37 am

I thought we wanted separation of church and state? Maybe put prayers back in school.

shoeless Texas
08/09/16 11:54 am

We do have that. The government isn't establishing a religion, not forcing it on anyone. If a church wants to suggest a candidate because of compatible beliefs, what's the harm? I believe that scares elected officials more than it is a church/state conflict.

rons on top of the world MA
08/09/16 1:20 pm

But if so someone put a cross out in the wilderness the ACLU has a fit because some anti theist cries like a baby about it. Or a religious group wants to hold a meeting in a school all hell breaks loose. But I seem plenty of politicians make their speeches at churches. Hillary's done a few in southern black churches.

skacey best poll is evenly split
08/08/16 9:30 pm

Sure, why not.

Presumably the members of a church have similar ideals and morals. Why would their leader not put forth their position on the matter?

Reply
political Georgia
08/08/16 9:22 pm

From the pulpit? That simply isn't right on so many levels.

Reply
ShawPPM1214 Washington
08/09/16 12:32 am

When I went door knocking for Mitt Romney I met a minister from a baptist church and he said he tells his congregation every election year who they should vote for.

political Georgia
08/09/16 7:14 am

He should focus on preaching God's word.

Carcano Luke 10 19
08/09/16 12:54 pm

There's nothing wrong with urging people to vote for a candidate or ballot question that falls in line with their religion.

political Georgia
08/09/16 1:16 pm

Teach Christian values, and people shouldn't have a difficult time figuring it out.