Show of HandsShow of Hands

Praetorianus August 9th, 2016 4:09am

If at some point in the near future genetic editing would be employed to create novelty pets that glow in the dark or combine traits of different animals, basically custom pets, then, provided the animals don't suffer, would it bother you?

15 Liked

Comments: Add Comment

corino Utah
08/09/16 7:26 pm

This is currently dome with fish. THE FUTURE is now.

Reply
dxstap Bloomington, Indiana
08/09/16 7:18 pm

Ahhhhh
The Island of Dr Moreau
H.G. Wells

Carcano Fir Na Dli
08/09/16 12:55 pm

No. I am 100% against messing with genes.

Reply
Carcano Fir Na Dli
08/09/16 12:56 pm

I mean Yes, it would bother me. Skimmed the question, my bad.

ainsleyy previously kitkat123
08/09/16 11:37 am

well knowing the human race, some dickhead is gonna invent a fire breathing dragon type shit and kill people

Reply
Liberty Lets Use Logic
08/09/16 5:24 am

Why would a new option on the market bother anyone? You don't have to buy one.

singkitty In the cloud
08/09/16 10:13 am

Because these are living animals and there is an abundance of them already in shelters.

lendluke iowa
08/09/16 11:09 am

I just thought some might be creepy. I don't think it should be illegal though.

Liberty Lets Use Logic
08/09/16 11:47 am

Kitty, what does that have to do with anything?

singkitty In the cloud
08/09/16 11:58 am

There are animals waiting for forever homes. Why add to the animal population when we are filling up our shelters with them?

Liberty Lets Use Logic
08/09/16 12:08 pm

But what does have to do with the poll or even the general topic?

Liberty Lets Use Logic
08/09/16 12:09 pm

Should car manufacturers stop coming out with newer models and new innovations because there is plenty of inventory in dealer lots already?

missmorganmarie ...
08/09/16 1:42 pm

you can't compare cars to living creatures.

Liberty Lets Use Logic
08/09/16 2:00 pm

It's the same logic.
"Because X product already exists in adequate supply to meet existing demand, new similar products should my be created."

singkitty In the cloud
08/09/16 2:54 pm

We aren't talking about products. This isn't about things, it's about living creatures.

Liberty Lets Use Logic
08/09/16 7:43 pm

Did you read the poll? It refers to pets, or animals. Do you think the two are mutually exclusive or something?

singkitty In the cloud
08/10/16 3:57 am

I'm not sure what you're asking. I think living creatures and pets are pretty mutually exclusive if that's what you're getting at.

Liberty Lets Use Logic
08/10/16 6:38 am

Ok, that's where the problem is. Why do you think that living creatures can't be pets?

singkitty In the cloud
08/10/16 6:39 am

I never said they couldn't.

Liberty Lets Use Logic
08/10/16 9:02 am

You just said that you though pets and living creatures are mutually exclusive. Do you no longer believe that?

singkitty In the cloud
08/10/16 10:39 am

I'm so sorry I mistyped that to a real point of confusion. I meant to say the two ARE NOT mutually exclusive. A cat or dog qualifies as a living creature/pet. Man I shouldn't be allowed on SOH before I drink coffee. Sorry!

singkitty In the cloud
08/09/16 4:48 am

Yes it would bother me. We have enough animals in need of adopting...we don't need to add more.

Reply
lendluke iowa
08/09/16 5:24 pm

Wouldn't the new creatures just replace a portion of the old ones instead of adding to them?

singkitty In the cloud
08/09/16 5:31 pm

Not unless all the strays magically were adopted prior to these new mutants.

spring27
08/09/16 3:02 am

Leave nature alone

Reply
Confucius Cage free No antibiotics
08/08/16 11:36 pm

Who's going to argue against me, when I have my glow-in-the-dark, weather resistant, fire breathing 1/2 aardvark 1/2 crocodile monster pet to protect me?

Reply
Praetorianus Fair enough.
08/08/16 11:52 pm

Your local fire department 😏

Laserbeam Crazy bird lady
08/08/16 9:30 pm

As a biologist, generally no that wouldn't bother me. As long as this is being done by experienced breeders who knows a thing or two about creating new lines of genetics. Irresponsible breeding irritates me.

Reply
RJ1969 SoCal
08/08/16 9:13 pm

I thought about doing this with fish sometime ago (make them glow in the dark). As it turns out, the laws governing this kind of thing are extensive.

RJ1969 SoCal
08/08/16 9:15 pm

This was 15 years ago, so...maybe they've lightened up.

singkitty In the cloud
08/09/16 4:51 am

Sheldon does it in an episode of Big Bang. Lol

Carcano Fir Na Dli
08/09/16 12:57 pm

I seriously doubt you'd get caught if you made your pet fish glow in the dark.

RJ1969 SoCal
08/09/16 1:04 pm

No, I wanted to sell them.

Praetorianus Fair enough.
08/08/16 9:12 pm

No, I'd apply the same ethic rules I'd like to see for ordinary breeding.
Don't create sickly breeds or breeds that have trouble leading a normal life.

Reply