Show of HandsShow of Hands

Mark3 December 18th, 2015 12:00pm

Nearly every one of you have agreed with me about the Middle East. What lessons might we get from these things on which we agree?

3 Liked

Comments: Add Comment

Odysseus We All Need A Fantasy
12/18/15 9:33 am

Kill the people who are trying to kill you and leave the rest alone.

LostTexan42 Deal With It
12/18/15 9:58 am

And doing so creates more people who want to kill you. Then kill them. Then create more. Then kill them. Then create more. Yay!

Ebola1 Florida
12/18/15 7:15 am

Shoot to kill.

Reply
political Georgia
12/18/15 7:01 am

Take the oil.

Reply
bigW7 USA
12/18/15 6:30 am

The region's been unstable since the mid20th century.

Your questions imply that US involvement sent the region spiraling into chaos. It was already there. Are things worse than they were 15 years ago? Probably. But I'm not totally convinced that lends credence to the hands-off approach that seems to be the implied policy of your question making.

For instance, you could phrase the question differently: have things gotten worse in the last handful of years, since we got boots off the ground? Absolutely.

It's hard to get an agreed-upon consensus as to what conclusions this yields.

Reply
Mark3
12/18/15 8:55 am

I agree with your response up to a point. It is not my stance that we should be hands off places that either kill/kidnap US citizens or interrupt peaceful trade, and Reagan's cruise missle response in Libya, for instance, seems reasonable.

Mark3
12/18/15 8:57 am

I'll assume your time reference is to WW II and the artificial nations created there and elsewhere.

googer11 Minnesota
12/18/15 9:11 am

It's been unstable since the bible.

LostTexan42 Deal With It
12/18/15 5:53 am

Unfortunately, our country is going to elect another war hawk who will use its soldiers and sailors as pawns to advance our horrible nation building strategy.

Mark3
12/18/15 5:10 am

I posted a number of questions about the Middle East and then this question to encourage conclusions.
This is the one SOH chose to close even though it was the most responded to.

Reply
LostTexan42 Deal With It
12/18/15 5:48 am

It closed because you hit your vote limit.

Mark3
12/18/15 5:07 am

Every large-scale military intervention should be agreed to by our representatives, and war declared.

Reply
Mark3
12/18/15 5:05 am

Our military is not a social service and should not used as such. It is for killing people and destroying things--seldom.

Mark3
12/18/15 5:03 am

Our military is neither for the benefit of the leaders of other countries nor the people thereof. It is for the protection of the US only.

Reply
Mark3
12/18/15 5:02 am

People should be naturally attracted to the example of the US, its freedoms and the benefits that accrue to a free people. We are much the better off by letting other people mind their business with what we are as a guiding light.

Reply