Show of HandsShow of Hands

Show Of Hands December 14th, 2015 11:34pm

To maintain U.S. continued military edge over China and Russia, Pentagon wants at least $12 billion to fund Artificial Intelligence based weapon technology in 2017. Do you find this a good use of taxpayer dollars?

77 Liked

Comments: Add Comment

SharpenedSavage USA
12/23/15 5:28 pm

AI weapon technology to me, simply means a program designed to see the psychological traits of human behavior and arrest you before you commit crime. Like the movie, Minority Report... Every hate crime leaves a before and after bread crumbs. I support it.

SharpenedSavage USA
12/23/15 5:19 pm

Great way to spend money... I vote for Robot teachers, police and politicians... All can be honest robots!!!

laika
12/20/15 9:42 pm

What exactly AI do they have in mind.

laika
12/22/15 11:49 pm

Asia, what part of AI don't you get?

cowboy Doors of Perception
12/17/15 8:26 am

If the Pentagon wants it, they'll get it. The rise of the machines.

Reply
Preox Earth
12/16/15 6:21 am

Instead of spending MORE money,spend less and spend smarter.

chnxbbc San Jose, CA
12/15/15 10:02 pm

We are the #1 biggest spender of military spending in the world. In front of China! We need to cut our military spending down by a lot

Reply
SharpenedSavage USA
12/23/15 5:20 pm

It keeps the sickos at bay...

DounutHole
12/15/15 7:34 pm

Ted(carpet bomb)Cruz is pro life. He wants to aimlessly bomb ISIS. ISIS is not a country or in just one country. Would Ted's strategy kill at least one innocent civilian?

SharpenedSavage USA
12/23/15 5:24 pm

Ted is Dumb cause he talks war and isn't even a Veteran. To kill Isis. Give them an island and let them have their way of life.

Captainbstring Biden is a Clown
12/15/15 2:58 pm

Leave the military to the experts.

Reply
lukecsa
12/15/15 2:52 pm

Speak softly and carry a big stick

Reply
flobotscott88
12/15/15 11:46 am

We already spend to much on the military as it is!

Reply
lukecsa
12/15/15 2:52 pm

And not nearly enough on education!!

Captainbstring Biden is a Clown
12/15/15 3:02 pm

So you suggest that we fall behind the other countries and become weaker and less prepared than this president has made us already? Also, MONEY has been proven not to be the silver bullet to improve education. The fix for education must come from the home. The parents must do their jobs BEFORE a teacher can teach a child.

lukecsa
12/15/15 3:03 pm

Captain... I was mocking him because he used the wrong "to/too" I don't agree with cutting defense spending whatsoever

Captainbstring Biden is a Clown
12/15/15 3:16 pm

Ok... Fair enough 😊

bnnt Los Angeles
12/15/15 8:36 am

Isn't that how Skynet in Terminator began?

Reply
Brandon2018 Stocks Are Overvalued
12/15/15 8:28 am

Its gonna turn on us. Why would I pay for that?

Reply
xarcos398
12/15/15 7:29 am

I was extremely septic sk at first but after reading the article, yeah I would give it a shot.

Reply
demandside New Keynesian
12/15/15 7:08 am

12 billion dollars to mantain in the pentagons ego?! I'll pass

Reply
arttie123 Progressive Independent
12/15/15 4:57 am

Lets just continue to spend until all of our budget is spent on military!

Reply
mynewipad north of southern calif
12/15/15 2:37 am

It's a little misleading since the $12B is for a variety of programs not just AI. The list of programs sounds like normal DARPA funding and the article didn't say if this is new funding ir just continuation

Reply
mynewipad north of southern calif
12/15/15 3:38 am

*OR just a continuation of existing funding and programs.

ParaguasPato Columbus GA
12/15/15 12:17 am

There are all sorts of movies detailing the dangers of self-controlling weapons, but the main concern really is that these weapons can be hacked by the enemy and then the code rewritten so that it will attack us instead, or just not attack at all.

Reply
dryanmorr
12/15/15 1:08 am

Which is why we need to make the best ones.

SonofMetal Heavy Metal
12/14/15 11:22 pm

Everyone is saying Skynet but I'm still excited about Fallout 4 so I'll say Roboco and Vault Tec πŸ‘±πŸΌπŸ‘πŸΌ

Reply
kutnejos000 Texas
12/14/15 11:21 pm

Ai is useless. We will still need the same old grunts as before. Ai will never match the creativity of the human mind.

Reply
Henry123 Connecticut
12/14/15 10:21 pm

Yes I'm ok with that because I believe we need to develope AI for other reasons.

Reply
ford5350 Houston
12/14/15 10:16 pm

either that or the arabs will get us

Reply
mark7569 Kentucky
12/14/15 10:15 pm

Do we really want to give the Chinese hackers a target like this???

mark7569 Kentucky
12/14/15 10:14 pm

I was going to post the same thing... All kinds of bad implications here.

Wooperth Blue Dog Democrat
12/14/15 10:01 pm

I am for defence spending, but AI is dangerous stuff. Hawking, Musk, and others have warned us of its dangers.

AI that could decide to go in for a kill on its own is dangerous. The day humans are outwit by machines means they are no longer in control.

Reply
RINOTom Peoria, IL
12/14/15 9:47 pm

Well this'll be about the most unpopular answer in the thread: I think it's kind of like climate change. It might seem a waste of money now, but there might come a day when we deeply regret not investing in staying ahead...

Reply
Octavian Phoenix
12/14/15 9:15 pm

While I think that the military is ridiculously over bloated, if we can inadvertently advance technology at large while funding the military, I'm for it

Reply
trav Instagram, travisdover
12/14/15 9:09 pm

Why don't they take it out of their massive military budget!?

Reply
jvberg Winter has Come
12/14/15 8:46 pm

Our military is already larger than China, Russia, and 8 other countries combined. I think we're more than ok with what we have

Reply
Congressman Louisiana
12/15/15 3:00 am

Are you high? Our military is not that big. You should probably pay a visit to google.com and ask who has the largest military.

jvberg Winter has Come
12/15/15 10:59 am

Ik we don't have the biggest standing army, but we spend more than the next 10 countries combined

EquaISideEcon more conservative than u
12/14/15 8:04 pm

Good idea bad price tag. The pentagon has consistently shown over the last two decades that it does not spend money effectively. Serious reforms should be taken so that the Pentagon may become far more efficient and ultimately spend less money.

Reply
FlipFlopGirl Sic semper tyrannis
12/14/15 8:58 pm

True but a lot of that $12B goes back into the economy and employs civilians, subcontractors, suppliers for parts, and multiple other types of services. Taxes are paid on that money and it's paid back to the local state and fed gov. Circle of life. Lol

Grimmy13
12/14/15 10:05 pm

The pentagon does not get to choose what to spend on. The vast majority is mandated by congress.

FlipFlopGirl Sic semper tyrannis
12/15/15 2:56 pm

It's not so black and white. Pentagon puts together a budget. Congress agrees. President signs. Congress gets broad categories - not individual line items. Pentagon gives out money to the branches, the commands and programs. I have some financial understanding of how it works in the DOD. I work for a working capital command, we pitch our services to the DoD FMS other agencies etc for RDT&E for the STEM areas. There is some flexibility as long as it fits time purpose and amount statutes in each program. The budget process is at a much higher level at Congress.

selfthink
12/14/15 8:00 pm

Skynet, here it comes

Reply
Crawdaddy11 LEGEND of FIRSTS
12/14/15 8:00 pm

Sure why not it's only a dozen billions

Liberty 4,032,064
12/14/15 7:58 pm

That's the opposite of what is good.

Reply
SticksandStones Stop fearmongering
12/14/15 7:50 pm

Uh, our military budget is about 5 times larger than China's. I think we're okay.

Reply
Grimmy13
12/14/15 10:12 pm

Really? China easily has over twice the active and reserve forces the U.S. has, a large ICBM capability, they are running SSBN patrols, have anti-satellite weapons, are building the Spratleys into armed fortresses and are cyber attacking us daily.

SticksandStones Stop fearmongering
12/14/15 10:15 pm

Your statement makes it seem like you doubt me. It is common knowledge that America has a more powerful (or at least more expensive) military that greatly surpasses China.

SonofMetal Heavy Metal
12/14/15 11:32 pm

Americas geographic location makes the Chinese reserve forces pretty invalid. Anti missile defense is probably our biggest concern.

corino Utah
12/15/15 10:10 am

There it is! "Let's arbitrarily compare the US military budget to other countries while ignoring geography, threats, history, resources, technology, etc etc etc". There are people whose job at the Pentagon is to think about what they do and don't need money for and they know congressman don't wanna give them any money because of armchair generals that want freedom without taxes.

JOEWmaUSA Massachusetts
12/14/15 7:42 pm

Use what is in the military budget now

Reply
Mackinaw Wolverine State, est.1837
12/14/15 7:31 pm

We don't need that garbage to fend off either of them, just a good navy. Let the European part of NATO pick up the slack and bring their militaries back up to reasonable strength. That would be deterrent enough.

Reply
SonofMetal Heavy Metal
12/14/15 11:30 pm

You realize the only reason they aren't is because we've essentially handed our strength to them? They have no reason to spend and build those things up when we already have it covered for them.

Mackinaw Wolverine State, est.1837
12/15/15 9:04 am

Which is why we should reduce our military investment

Zod Above Pugetropolis
12/14/15 7:29 pm

I really don't think the same clowns that want to spy on our every move while at the same time prove over and over and over they can't even protect their own data much less ours should be given the money to develop autonomous weapons, because they really do seem dumb enough to do just that if we let them. And then they'll be all like "Huh, did not see that coming" when the things go Skynet on us. Or even more likely, when they get hacked and are used against us.

Reply
svenalexander Land of the Ents
12/14/15 7:27 pm

Figures... Republicans are for it while everyone else is against it. This is why Libertarians need to take over the GOP - they actually make sense next to Democrats

Reply
BatmansParents Monarch Theater
12/14/15 7:40 pm

Those people are RINOS and sadly some speak for the party. The Republican Party supports a smaller gov and I would certainly oppose this vehemently if I were in power and refuse to enforce the law on this issue and if i was a state leader I would call for a revolution/secession because of the infringement of rights

RadicalRight Reactionary Heaven
12/15/15 11:22 am

Because robots are spooki and you would prefer us to lose the next world war..

aidenrobo woburn MA
12/14/15 7:25 pm

Our military is strong enough way surpassing the others we do not need to fight computers if the project goes wrong

Reply
mrscheisskopf2 Kentucky
12/14/15 7:12 pm

We're still far ahead of them

Reply
Rotavele Alabama
12/14/15 7:09 pm

I'm anti-defense spending hikes, but we're falling far behind in the Artif. Intelligence race and AI tech can help the people a lot as well.

Reply
DiQuellaPira
12/14/15 6:57 pm

SkyNet Funding Bill?

Reply
thesleepwolf florida
12/14/15 6:53 pm

Has no one seen terminator?

Reply
CTYankee!!! Connecticut
12/14/15 6:47 pm

Pentagon or Halliburton?
Perhaps Lockheed-Martin.
Or General Dynamics.

Reply
4boot LaTrineodeur, MN
12/14/15 6:46 pm

Sure, $12 Bil is just chump change in the US budget...our military must keep its technological edge.

Reply
TheLibertarian
12/14/15 6:45 pm

Sky net anyone?

Reply
niceshotman
12/14/15 6:51 pm

There is no fate but what we make ourselves.