Show of HandsShow of Hands

veritas1 December 13th, 2015 7:41pm

Student A (poor) loves science but can't get an internship because he has to work a min wage summer job. Student B interns at his dad's lab over the summer, gaining skills A doesn't get. Should a competitive university only accept the Student Bs?

12 Liked

Comments: Add Comment

johndoe88 rural
12/13/15 7:48 pm

Should they- No, Do they, not all the time, Dose student B have an "unfair" advantage, No, he still has to be committed, and it's because his parents did there work and got him that opportunity. Student A could work toward a better life for his offspring butting their needs way before his own, which is a grate accomplishment within itself.... Sorry I got a little to deep...

Arbiter7
12/13/15 7:02 pm

There are other factors to consider, so no.

Reply
fluxcap Philadelphia
12/13/15 5:12 pm

Why would the students be accepted only this basis. Is the question "all other things being equal" or are we only to judge on this fact?

Reply
AKCowboysFan Anchorage m8
12/13/15 5:40 pm

I believe the point is to shed some light on why colleges giving preferential treatment to underprivileged applicants makes sense

fluxcap Philadelphia
12/13/15 6:11 pm

I get that, but potential students are far more than just a summer internship.

CrzyChica
12/13/15 8:55 pm

AKCowboysFan, that's what I thought this question was getting at, too.

ndull Minnesota
12/13/15 3:13 pm

Well they're both working but why is Student A confined to working in the summer?

RB20 Indiana
12/13/15 2:57 pm

He can love it all he wants, can he do it tho?

drkwrl
12/13/15 2:52 pm

There's always grad school. Is this in the context of undergrad admissions?

kscott516 Masks fail
12/13/15 2:44 pm

"Gaining skills", so yes, student B.

Rosebud Ohio
12/13/15 1:05 pm

No.
Work experience is important too fwiw.