Show of HandsShow of Hands

think4yourself December 11th, 2015 7:14pm

If you own a business and the government took some of your money and gave it to someone else to spend in your store, have they benefitted you by creating a customer for you?

15 Liked

Comments: Add Comment

F1Dan Parked in your spot
12/15/15 6:49 pm

If they spend more than the government took, then yes, it helped you (a little bit.) If they become return customers then even better.

FarmerManE djent
12/14/15 8:04 am

Probably not considering the government will take a considerable amount for them selves

Reply
Idahologger up north
12/12/15 11:59 pm

Punish the hard working, reward the lazy, makes sense...

Reply
Captainbstring Biden is a Clown
12/13/15 5:48 pm

Agree. Dumb, dumb, dumb.

logicalphallus Minnesota
12/12/15 10:24 am

If this weren't effective, there would be no such thing as free samples.

Reply
sea California
12/12/15 3:46 pm

That's only true if you give away a free sample that is minuscule in value compared to what the customer ends up buying.

logicalphallus Minnesota
12/12/15 4:31 pm

Yeah I guess there's a difference in value. If the government just gives a guy a car from the Ford dealer, it doesn't necessarily mean he'll come back again to buy another car.

evoecon nearest binary system
12/12/15 6:25 am

Six pence none the richer.

The government has just increased the price to place that product on the shelf. The store owner passes this cost along to the consumers. The store owner does not pay the tax, the consumers pay the tax. So, the poor paid more for the government to "create" another customer.

Reply
Carolynn new jersey
12/12/15 6:01 am

If it's a good business, it may benefit. That customer could become a long-term customer, coming back multiple times over several years. They can even bring in new business by word of mouth. They can refer friends and family members who come in to spend some of their money. I think that's better than if the customer never set foot in my store.

Reply
htcbump Florida
12/11/15 9:42 pm

Any money they took is profit, and then spent to rebuy is COGS plus profit. If your profit is 6% you lose 94%.

Reply
Arbiter7
12/11/15 4:05 pm

That literally means they get the good for free (or if they don't buy that money's worth or don't buy at all, they get money). It's like the SpongeBob episode where SpongeBob gave Patrick a quarter to spend on the bubble lessons he was giving.

Reply
jvc1133 61535
12/11/15 2:48 pm

No, it was just a looker. 😂

Metamorphosis
12/11/15 1:57 pm

Yes, of course. Health Insurance, Day Care, Super Markets, the Military Industrial Complex, the Construction Industry and the Pharmaceutical Industry all benefit enormously from taking tax money and putting it back into the economy.

Happy Hong Kong
12/11/15 1:56 pm

That sounds like Bernie Sanders' idea of a sound and progressive economic policy.

Reply
Kneske College Station, TX
12/11/15 1:23 pm

If it's a good business, it doesn't need the government's help getting customers. If it's a bad business that needs help getting customers, it shouldn't last long anyways. Capitalism.

Reply
dale41 Grand Master of FIRSTS
12/11/15 12:40 pm

It's even worse when that potentially customer goes to a different store.

Reply
AbandonedAccnt Not here.
12/11/15 12:39 pm

Sounds like the business owner got robbed.

Reply
political Georgia
12/11/15 12:17 pm

That's not sound logic.

Reply
think4yourself Not a safe space
12/11/15 12:32 pm

True. Yet somehow this idea popular when presented as taxing businesses more is good for them because the redistributed money creates customers for them.