Show of HandsShow of Hands

Comments: Add Comment

arste New York
10/23/12 4:02 pm

I'm biased. When do we get a third option so I can vote for Jim Kelly? Go Bills!!!

Reply
ladyniner81 I need chocolate
10/23/12 8:03 am

Montana made me a Niners fan, so I'm a homer..Besides, he DID have success in KC. He was cool as a cucumber in the pocket, and he was smart. Both Montana & Elway were fun to watch, along with Marino and Kelly.

Reply
Feelyfeel
10/22/12 12:12 am

Two phrases come to mind: "Montana to Clark" and "Montana to Rice"


10/21/12 11:39 pm

Yeah, it didn't have anything to do with the rest of the team at all huh?

Ugh.


10/21/12 11:38 pm

Actually, Joe Montana did that against the Broncos defense.

John Elway didn't play defense so......

Reply
TheOnEdgePro Area 52
10/21/12 7:06 pm

Montana proves that height isn't a factor to becoming a great QB.

jagger
10/21/12 1:50 pm

This isn't even close do u remember what Montana did to elway and the broncos in the superbowl

CSGraham
10/21/12 10:31 am

And just a better QB. SF doesn't win anything w/o Montana. Denver could have won their 2 superbowls with another QB.

CSGraham
10/21/12 10:29 am

If you're picking who you like that's one thing. If you're picking who's better, those who pick Elway are homers or naive.

Reply
tdaddy Kentucky
10/21/12 8:55 am

Huh? Are we picking a baby name? If so I like John Montana best!

MrWalrus Undergrid
10/21/12 5:05 am

Bill only coached Montana for three of his four Super Bowls, so no he was not a product of Walsh's system. He also had some success with KC. Elway was sloppy and undisciplined. That is why it took him so long to win a SB.

MrWalrus Undergrid
10/21/12 4:57 am

Elway only has two rings, Montana has four.

itanimulli
10/21/12 12:42 am

I like John Montana.

Reply
AvaholicLife
10/20/12 11:34 pm

I wonder why colorado is the only state that voted mostly for Elway? True fans, true fans. So how about those awesome hockey games? Lol this is going to be a long year for me.

Reply
young2031
10/20/12 10:06 pm

4 Superbowls. Cool under pressure. Totally unflappable. Classy and simply the best: Joe Montana. John Elway was temperamental and a spoiled brat when he didn't get his way. It was all about him. Joe was a team player and was respected by his coaches and teammates alike.

Reply

10/20/12 9:38 pm

I said Joe, but did some research, really good question. One stat stood out: joe Montana no interceptions in 4 Superbowls. That's cold as hell!!

Reply
Jabes
10/20/12 7:02 pm

This is the first sports question, other than ones asking if I watched games, that I ever felt inclined to answer.

Zod Above Pugetropolis
10/20/12 7:01 pm

Elway, no contest. Willing to calmly wait forever for an open receiver, and willing to take the hit if nobody got free. Montana could get rid of the ball faster than a scared little girl if it even looked like he might get dinged.

Reply
USA1st
10/20/12 6:45 pm

lol I know a guy named Joe Montana.

Reply
Listen2cKy Redding, CA
10/20/12 5:48 pm

If Elway was in Bill Walsh's system there would have been no comparison. I like Montana, but he was successful because of his coach. Elway could throw farther and run laps around Joe.

producto
10/20/12 4:36 pm

Warren Moon!

Reply
UGonnaEatThat
10/20/12 3:46 pm

Aside from the fact that Montana was a better player, Elway is a douchebag.

Reply
chenzo13
10/20/12 3:07 pm

Montana. Period.

Reply
GoFlo Peace Through Strength
10/20/12 2:40 pm

...But, if all things were equal, I'd say Elway was better. Bigger, stronger could throw the deep ball. Montana threw a lot of crossing routes.

GoFlo Peace Through Strength
10/20/12 2:40 pm

Montana had a better supporting cast his whole career except when he went to KC. He was older of course. Elway had lesser players, still good, but he was still able to play very well...

rustican
10/20/12 12:54 pm

No he's not a car salesman. He owned a dealership while he was playing but he sold it. He's not even in the industry anymore

Reply
BroncosRN
10/20/12 12:27 pm

You realize he is now the Vice President of football operations with the Denver Broncos...right?

Reply
BroncosRN
10/20/12 12:26 pm

If Elway played on teams as good as Montana did then this wouldn't even be a question. Instead Elway played on subpar teams which he carried on his back for the majority of his career, making Montana seem like a more prolific QB.

Reply
Lordofguitar
10/20/12 12:10 pm

Jim Kelly!!! :D

Reply
cato Santa Barbara, California
10/20/12 11:49 am

Ya. Montana by a mile.

Reply
timeout Boston Strong
10/20/12 11:17 am

Not even close. Joe Montana could be the greatest of all time. Four Super Bowl wins. Number 16 new how to close a game.

Reply
PeppyHare Do a barrel roll
10/20/12 11:06 am

Elway, but I'm too young to have seen Montana. Elway was like a Brett favre who knew enough to leave at the top.

Gunfighter
10/20/12 11:03 am

Neither. Johnny Unitas

Reply
hazhap1 Las Vegas
10/20/12 10:51 am

Elway is a skeezy car salesman now. Yuck!

Reply
snafu Washington
10/20/12 10:17 am

No clue who they are, football players? I picked Montana since it sounds familiar.

Reply
fng
10/20/12 9:58 am

Elway took mediocre teams far with his great play( until the end when he had great teams and won championships). Montana isn't in the top 20 when it comes to great qb's. Montana was a moderately talented player on one of the greatest teams ever.

Reply
Quinnipiac Here
10/20/12 9:21 am

This user is currently being ignored

KudosToYou California
10/20/12 9:16 am

Montana could actually play a full game.

Reply
goalie31 OrthodoxCatholicChristian
10/20/12 9:16 am

Joe Montana went to my High school... Ringgold ftw

Reply
rustican
10/20/12 9:15 am

Elway is the man

Reply
jimmyjelly BFE, PA
10/20/12 9:11 am

Montana is from PA. We have a bridge named after him.

Reply
tdyakker lost
10/20/12 9:09 am

Haven't been able to watch a game since he left. Elway all the way.

mac Oregon
10/20/12 9:09 am

Toughest poll ever :)

Reply
PurpleAsh Nowhere Land, CO
10/20/12 9:06 am

First. Elway all the way

Reply