Show of HandsShow of Hands

MrWolfe March 17th, 2015 1:26am

In the spirit of 'March Madness,' HBO's John Oliver has taken on the issue of college athletes not being compensated, despite having their likeness used for revenue by schools & sponsors. Should student-athletes receive some type of monetary stipend?

13 Liked

Comments: Add Comment

jonny323
03/17/15 11:18 pm

They should be paid at least min wage for the number of hours they spend practicing. They don't have the option of working while playing sports and the amount of effort put into being a D1 student athlete is more than most full time jobs.

xXDOGEMASTERXx Nebraska
03/17/15 6:03 pm

No, but if you don't, give them the chance to go pro earlier. Or at least give them the chance to make their own money

ozzy
03/17/15 4:56 pm

No. They often have full ride scholarships, and receive special treatment in other ways.

Naterade Rhode Island
03/17/15 12:13 pm

No. They already get a free education and meals from scholarships.

timeout Boston Strong
03/17/15 11:40 am

I think it should stay the way it is. The fact that the are getting a free education should be good enough for them. They also are given the chance to showcase their talents for a shot at the pros while on a scholarship.

Reply
Squidboy Snarkapottamus
03/17/15 10:44 am

NCAA athletes are not allowed to work. A small and equal stipend of a few hundred a month to cover living expenses is reasonable.

Beefsquatch
03/17/15 10:27 am

It's not an even playing field. If colleges don't want to pay them, athletes should get a guaranteed 4-5 yr scholarship, regardless of future injury or ineligibility in exchange for the athlete's commitment.

Beefsquatch
03/17/15 11:28 am

The medical student argument is a straw man at best. This debate does not exist because medical students are bringing in billions like the NCAA. They'd need to cure cancer to compete.

eLucidate writing
03/17/15 9:07 am

Yes. I'd rather see them get real money than fake degrees.

Reply
OnlyRationalOne ifunny aManWitNoHands
03/17/15 8:16 am

Most big athletes are getting free tuition, food, and housing. What more should they get?

Reply
deist
03/17/15 9:17 am

Instead of giving them money they should have the opportunity to return at any time in there life to continue to pursue or further there education at there alma mater.

whatever FL
03/17/15 8:01 am

Like many have said, a college education ain't nothing. (Heh.) Besides that, there are other options available, including playing internationally, to get around the college requirement. Could options be more and better, yet viable? I couldn't say.

Beefsquatch
03/17/15 11:47 am

The "N" stands for "National." In this country, students cannot go from h.s. To the pros. Why? B/c the NCAA wants their cut. To avoid that, the athlete must risk injury elsewhere for less exposure and compensation. Fair?

droo Santa Barbara
03/16/15 11:00 pm

I'd say free college is a good start, which they have.

Reply
DJE99 California
03/16/15 10:52 pm

They do get paid. It's called free education.

Reply
Beefsquatch
03/17/15 12:11 pm

Unless they get injured while fulfilling their commitment. Then they lose that scholarship and any possible pro opportunities, and got no benefit from the ticket sales they drew. NCAA - $$. Student athlete - 0.

Alex619 California
03/16/15 10:23 pm

Well considering we shouldn't have any government run schools this is a debate to be had for individual schools. The market will speak on this issue like it will for anything else.

Reply
NOTColonelWest
03/16/15 10:01 pm

I've said it before, and I'll say it again. Thy should have the right to license their own image and profit from it, but they should not be paid by the colleges or the NCAA

Reply
4boot LaTrineodeur, MN
03/16/15 9:57 pm

College athletes should be real students taking real classes...and shouldn't get paid beyond their scholarships.

Reply
RobH
03/17/15 7:11 am

And why is that?

Jay716 Buffalo NY
03/16/15 9:51 pm

I can see them being compensated for jersey sales and NCAA video games, but nothing else. Autographs are okay too.

Reply
chrismisen atlanta
03/16/15 9:02 pm

im torn on this. colleges don't have a monopoly on amateur basketball, so players arent forced to accept scholarship as sole payment, but it's borderline criminal how much some schools make from their athletics without sharing it with the players

Reply
steelcity Pittsburgh
03/16/15 7:30 pm

Because free college education isn't compensation?

Reply
Wino I need a drink
03/16/15 9:47 pm

Most don't really get a good education. All our athletes were told to take easy courses so school wouldn't interfere with their schedule. When some took harder classes (knowing they weren't going pro), they were punished with extra practices.

Rainey 633 Stag Trail Road
03/16/15 7:19 pm

I literally just got done watching that episode 😳

Reply
Rainey 633 Stag Trail Road
03/16/15 7:21 pm

What an eye opener.

osouless Whats Next
03/16/15 6:39 pm

Only when their likenesses are being used.

Reply
Zod Above Pugetropolis
03/16/15 6:35 pm

Isn't that what the scholarship is? Because the cost of a year's tuition, housing and books seems like a pretty good paycheck for a guy without a degree and no real-world experience. It's like the new kid at McDonalds wanting to share the profits.

Reply
TheCameron UCF
03/16/15 7:18 pm

Except in this case nearly every kid in that area is wearing a jersey with his name on it.

Dandilionz Caveat lector
03/16/15 7:29 pm

Zod I agree. Also when their likeness is being used it is promotion for their skill and to be noticed and drafted.

Zod Above Pugetropolis
03/16/15 7:35 pm

Good for him. That might pay off for him someday, if he goes pro or can leverage that little bit of local celebrity into some kind of better paying gig. Even if you consider it a business, trainee employees don't usually make top dollar.

Beefsquatch
03/17/15 12:26 pm

The kid @ McDonald's can use his check to invest in Mcdonalds stock. Also, if the kid @ McDonalds is injured on the job, he can collect worker's comp. it is not close to being the same.