Show of HandsShow of Hands

Rotavele October 31st, 2014 2:37pm

(Intriguing or Crazy?) So today I heard a new one. A person of another ideology explained to me that because Jesus was a socialist, they decided to become an atheist for that reason.

12 Liked

Comments: Add Comment

TheGodless
11/01/14 12:59 am

Render unto Caesar right? That certainly doesn't sound very Republican.

Reply
TheGodless
11/01/14 12:55 am

If Jesus is also the Biblical god, he is actually a convoluted mess of ideologies. At times he is a communist demanding everyone give their riches away and other times he is a socialist encouraging charity, but mostly he is just a genocidal dictator.

Reply
PresWK Minnesota
10/31/14 9:14 pm

Even though I'm a socialist, I think he was more of a libertarian because he taught others to treat people right and leave them alone and would probably therefore have a more voluntarist view.

Reply
pd15
10/31/14 7:48 pm

Jesus was more of a communist than a socialist

Reply
ThomasK
10/31/14 5:04 pm

You don't choose to be an atheist. You either believe there is some sort of god or you don't. My guess is this person still believes entirely.

Reply
RedHale Texas
10/31/14 4:45 pm

Jesus wasn't socialist. He believed in choosing to give to people, not choosing to steal from them.

Reply
Rotavele Alabama
10/31/14 10:08 pm

I disagree. Not exactly, refusing to give to people when you had plenty is greed. A seven deadly sin.

MannIsMe Did You Assume My Party
10/31/14 4:20 pm

Taking politics more serious than religion? Whoa.

Reply
rons screw politicians
10/31/14 2:24 pm

Jesus always confused me! Was he a nomad that roamed around and caused trouble or what.

Reply
Zod Above Pugetropolis
10/31/14 1:40 pm

I'd have explained that the Jesus is just one of many, many choices. They can't all be socialists. That just doesn't seem like a very good reason to become an anything to me.

CudOfCow Oregon
10/31/14 12:50 pm

Rejecting the idea that Jesus is a god does not make you an atheist.

Reply
CudOfCow Oregon
10/31/14 12:50 pm

It just makes you non Christian.

Rotavele Alabama
10/31/14 10:09 pm

He said he was Athiest.

CudOfCow Oregon
11/02/14 3:49 pm

I dont think he understands the concept.

RepMorris Pennsylvania
10/31/14 12:04 pm

Jesus was not a socialist.

Reply
corino Utah
10/31/14 11:39 am

Socialist? He claimed to be King. When he was crucified that was his crime. People walked past and saw a man on a cross dying with a sign over his head 'King of the Jews'.

Reply
corino Utah
10/31/14 11:45 am

Calls himself the divine right Monarch of Heaven and Earth. When he says feed the hungry that isn't for the benefit of a the social order that's for the benefit of the Monarch.

USA1st
10/31/14 11:09 am

Jesus was no socialist...

Reply
profligatesoul
10/31/14 10:52 am

Wow that's interesting. Placing political ideology above religious ideology? Maybe they didn't fully grasp the whole religion thing.

Reply
AbandonedAccnt Not here.
10/31/14 10:50 am

You have to play twister with the Bible to get to the socialist part. I've even seen people say that Jesus was gay. People can get whatever they want from it.

Reply
shnibbydawhale Nihilist
10/31/14 10:19 am

Jesus was most certainly not a socialist. And no republicans, Jesus was not a white conservative. Get over yourselves.

Reply
Rotavele Alabama
10/31/14 10:36 am

That's what I expect, someone to say "Hey he's our party" or something. However this just baffled me.

Brrrrrrrrr
10/31/14 9:29 am

Yes, many people become atheists via catastrophically stupid and illogical reasoning. This is neither shocking nor news.

Reply
Arananthi Literal Ninja
10/31/14 10:49 am

'change religio-philisophical viewpoints'*

jvc1133 61535
10/31/14 9:24 am

Well if we're proven he was "Obama progressive socialist", I would be frightened.

Rotavele Alabama
10/31/14 10:38 am

Jesus would likely be a socialist in a neutral civic sense. As in he wouldn't feed the poor to help the economy grow, he'd just feed the poor. He would however heal to heal even if it's expensive.
He said "if you don't work you don't eat" which is

Rotavele Alabama
10/31/14 10:39 am

What republicans usually use in defense of feeding the poor argument (both), but he also said help your neighbor. (socialism)

I think he'd be a generic socialist, not progressive as he isn't working towards anything.

susanr Colorado
10/31/14 9:21 am

That doesn't make any sense to me from angle I try to look at it, so I'm going with crazy. Although it could just be... dumb, I guess.

Reply
TopsQueen Oregon Coast
10/31/14 9:16 am

Crazy with the the word but pretty close to it. Jesus was about faith in God not about political ideologies

Reply
MrMilkdud
10/31/14 9:17 am

Exactly. Jesus didn't take sides on government or economic models.
He was all about personal responsibility.

Rotavele Alabama
10/31/14 10:42 am

I completely agree. Usually he's regarded as social for his equal treatment and assisting the poor. However he had no agenda or goals, so he wasn't politically socialist, just socialist in behavior. Kind of.. Sort of.. Lol.

Arananthi Literal Ninja
10/31/14 10:54 am

'Truly, I say to you, as you did it to one of the least of these my brethren, you did it to me.'

Odysseus We All Need A Fantasy
10/31/14 8:40 am

If Jesus himself were to give his Sermon on the Mount speech at both Party conventions, he would be applauded by the Democrats and booed off the stage by the GOP.

Reply
hrankta
10/31/14 8:28 am

Jesus wasn't a socialist.

Reply
hrankta
10/31/14 11:10 am

Like I said, Jesus wasn't a socialist, and a leftist's misunderstanding of Bible verses doesn't change it.

hrankta
10/31/14 11:15 am

The author also doesn't try to make the case that Jesus was a socialist.

suppressedID That is my secret Cap
10/31/14 7:45 am

Dogma trumping faith.
Class act. :-/

Reply
Rotavele Alabama
10/31/14 8:00 am

Yes but most people of faith claim that Jesus wasn't a socialist and back it up. I am trying to figure out if this person may have been like heavily scarred by a socialist person, or what's going on. I can't believe "leaving God behind for politics".

Rotavele Alabama
10/31/14 8:01 am

It's just not normal and it's a mystery. I stopped commenting so I didn't seem like I was prying and nosey but I really want to know why. Lol.

eLucidate writing
10/31/14 7:42 am

That seems crazy to me.

Reply
Rotavele Alabama
10/31/14 7:38 am

It may be from the lack of sleep but this was so unique to me that I just couldn't understand. I've heard of changing parties for religious purposes, but giving up religion because of mortals? It's new and I wanted to know more about it.

Reply
Rotavele Alabama
10/31/14 7:39 am

I wasn't sure if this is an interesting subject to others or if it seems too out there to be interesting to them. I've had a lack of sleep so I may just be a bit weird on this one. :P

If anyone knows someone similar, feel free to explain deeper.