Show of HandsShow of Hands

Praetorianus October 25th, 2014 1:27am

Somebody tries to pet an animal while the owner isn't present, such as a dog roaming in a garden or a horse in a paddock and gets bitten. He wasn't trespassing, the animal reached through or over the enclosure. Should the owner be liable for injury?

18 Liked

Comments: Add Comment

FarmerManE djent
10/27/14 7:28 am

Animals bite. It shouldn't take too much brain power to realize that

rangeman Lafayette IN.
10/26/14 9:57 am

Be accountable for your own actions!!

Reply
yorkie62
10/25/14 10:43 pm

Animals are not predictable. Even while an owner is near by.

Reply
NikkiKitti47
10/25/14 9:53 pm

No most children are taught not to pet animals unless ok with owner or was it just me?

Reply
ladyniner81 I hate people
10/25/14 7:30 pm

Were they warned? they could've been warned and then expect to be paid for their dumbassery. NADA

Reply
MrMilkdud
10/25/14 6:25 pm

You're responsible for your own stupidity.

Reply
rons Thanks America
10/25/14 5:26 pm

Saying nice doggie means nothing to the dog.

Reply
Zod Above Pugetropolis
10/25/14 4:43 pm

Somebody tries to pet me they're risking more than just getting bitten - unless she's old enough and cute, in which case
I'll allow it. Wife might get a little ornery though. If you reach for an animal without an invitation, the bite is your fault.

Reply
bluerum29 optimistic idealist
10/24/14 8:30 pm

I was walking on a trail with my dog one time and a group came by. I told them she's not good with strangers (she was a very protective dog). He pet her anyway and she nipped at him and broke skin. He asked for a phone number, I have him a fake one

Reply
jmw7477 Indiana
10/24/14 7:10 pm

You take a risk petting an animal you don't know.

Reply
TheCameron UCF
10/24/14 7:02 pm

The owner has an enclosure in place so the owner has fulfilled his legal requirements to not be liable in my opinion.

Reply
Praetorianus Fair enough.
10/24/14 6:29 pm

No, this is different from an unprovoked animal attack. You should never pet a strange animal, and if it was a child, children too young to know this shouldn't be left unsupervised.

Reply
Praetorianus Fair enough.
10/24/14 6:32 pm

Inspired by a medieval "real story" song where a horse bit off someone's finger. He sued. The outcome isn't recorded but the fact the court took the case and the owner resorted to claiming he didn't own the horse shows it's not totally clear cut.