Show of HandsShow of Hands

AbandonedAccnt October 23rd, 2014 1:47pm

Some people call jihadists "mentally ill" because they kill innocent people. Is this a "cop out" intended to discredit them without having to consider their reasoning, religious values, and culture?

8 Liked

Comments: Add Comment

dxstap Bloomington, Indiana
10/23/14 3:41 pm

I don't think they are mentally ill but value structure is really screwed up.

Reply
Krystina Let Freedom Reign
10/23/14 9:53 am

They are mentally ill only if following one's religious doctrine in a very literal sense indicate's mental illness.

Reply
duey in a fools paradise
10/23/14 9:43 am

I think those of us in the west can't even imagine the desperation in these countries. That alone would make people nuts! But everyone has choices to make being an entrapanuer or doing for others is hard work, the easy path is destruction.

Reply
aj1545 Cat Lady
10/23/14 9:27 am

I think it is. Someone who says that doesn't understand mental illness. Mental illness isn't a choice. Maybe they're heavily influenced to be jihadists, or even coerced. Doesn't make it a mental illness.

Reply
dlaw4570
10/23/14 9:23 am

Sorry about that, wrong button. As I was saying I have never heard of a jihadist being referred to as mentally ill. Crazy yes. It is not an illness, mental or otherwise. Although I suspect the mentally ill would be more inclined to become a jihadist

AbandonedAccnt Not here.
10/23/14 9:32 am

Some commentator in Canada was saying he thought the people who shot up the parliament yesterday must have been mentally ill for wanting to do that. I've heard people many times say that killers must have a mental illness or they wouldn't do that.

dlaw4570
10/23/14 10:29 am

A commentator is your source? Sorry I missed that talking head

ScrewU Gone
10/23/14 2:52 pm

I've said exactly the same thing about school shooters. These people aren't mentally ill. They hate society (or certain parts) and they want to hurt it. All evil is not necessarily irrational.

dlaw4570
10/23/14 9:18 am

I'm trying to understand the question...I have never heard of a

statgat Hello World
10/23/14 9:03 am

They are not mentally ill. They have a perfect understanding of what they are doing

Reply
GlockMan1 Alabama
10/23/14 8:11 am

It was this same mentality that brought on THE CRUSADES.

GlockMan1 Alabama
10/23/14 8:10 am

They kill because their hearts are wicked and Satan has deceived them into believing God is with them. Has nothing to do with mental illness.

Reply
duey in a fools paradise
10/23/14 7:19 am

Sorry I see them as brainwashed killers just like the Mason family. Weak minded, undereducated with no idea how to do anything positive. Actually they view killing infidel's as a positive venture. Had these people been brought into Jim Jones's church

Reply
duey in a fools paradise
10/23/14 7:23 am

they would have literally drank the Kool-Aid. They have no idea how to treat women or children other then property. The Mullahs in these backward countries have easy prey almost ready made pieces of clay waiting to be molded into destructive killers.

AbandonedAccnt Not here.
10/23/14 7:29 am

Their religious views are not new and are as old as Islam itself. Their spiritual leaders (imams and such) are schooled and trained in Islam. Their scholars are as educated as any university professor at any theological school in the US.

duey in a fools paradise
10/23/14 7:33 am

I agree but their students have no foundation other then what any given Imam what's to teach. Unfortunately they've been inclined to teach the old violent barbaric laws in it's most literal form.

AbandonedAccnt Not here.
10/23/14 7:34 am

They have solid backing for their islamic beliefs and their interpretation is well supported by the literal islamic text. I don't think they're crazy at all. I think they just subscribe to a really bad version of the religion.

duey in a fools paradise
10/23/14 7:42 am

The Imams agreed aren't crazy, the students are what the Imam's will make of them. Today's churches could teach a literal version of the Old Testament and we could be in the same place but modern theologians here teach it more as a piece of

duey in a fools paradise
10/23/14 7:44 am

literature. They focus on the much more positive aspects using the bible as a guide to serve and forgive not hate and destroy.

Optimus1
10/23/14 7:59 am

I agree the scholars of Islam are educated. It's the followers who appear to be brainwashed. I understand the Quran gives guidance and orders for jihad, but I haven't seen one scholar, leader or warlord strap a bomb to themselves for the 40 virgins.

Optimus1
10/23/14 8:01 am

This is something they conveniently delegate out to the "expendable". Osama bin laden made video discussing this, while laughing that they gave their lives on 9-11

gonzoboy Northern AZ
10/23/14 7:08 am

"No", I don't think it a "cop out", 'cuz along with other references, they're also certifiably deranged Muslim zealots. All discrediting to culture/religion is what they themselves have done. We merely acknowledge. I could care less their reasoning.

Liberty 4,032,064
10/23/14 7:06 am

Yes, as with many, maybe most, cases where people use that term.

Reply
ScrewU Gone
10/23/14 7:03 am

That's exactly what it is. I've been face to face with some of these guys in Iraq. They aren't fanatics and they're not crazy. They will tell you calmly but with utter certainty why they must do what they do.

Reply
ScrewU Gone
10/23/14 7:04 am

They're obligated by the demands of Islam, if that wasn't clear.

AbandonedAccnt Not here.
10/23/14 7:05 am

I agree. It's hard for people to grasp and they don't want to believe that some religion is really this way. At the same time, however, they'll gleefully point to Middle Age Christianity and ascribe to it the characteristics of modern Jihad.

AbandonedAccnt Not here.
10/23/14 7:09 am

Of course not all Muslims subscribe to this interpretation of scripture (most don't), but that doesn't change the validity of the interpretation for those who do.

AbandonedAccnt Not here.
10/23/14 6:48 am

I think it's an easy way to avoid having to consider the religious and cultural reasons behind what they do. It's easy to label people in order to make quick sense of something that we don't understand or don't want to acknowledge.

Reply
AbandonedAccnt Not here.
10/23/14 6:54 am

And for the record I think they're despicable human beings, but they do have a good faith belief in their religion.