Show of HandsShow of Hands

political February 6th, 2014 10:53pm

A judge today ruled that warning motorists by flashing headlights is a first amendment right. Do you agree with his decision?

29 Liked

Comments: Add Comment

Kells
02/09/14 5:42 pm

I worked in law enforcement for years. Consider this: on the other side of the hill is a road block. Officers are searching for a man that just killed 4 kids in a hit and run accident. Now, you trying to be a fine friend, just helped him escape...

matt0806 Port Huron
02/08/14 7:36 am

How is this a first amendment right.

Reply
Zod Above Pugetropolis
02/07/14 11:49 pm

Yes except that most of the people who do so are too lazy to use their low beams, opting instead to flash their high beams, which is probably a violation in most areas. Day or night, aiming the high beams at oncoming traffic is annoying.

Zimmeress Make Me Laugh
02/09/14 12:56 pm

I don't have low beams- so how would I remedy that?

Zod Above Pugetropolis
02/09/14 1:40 pm

You must have some kind of low beams. Even if they are the kind that are on all the time you can turn them off then back on to "flash" them. It may be legal to use the high beams. In WA there are specific distances from other traffic to be legal.

Zimmeress Make Me Laugh
02/09/14 1:45 pm

Turnings lights off at night makes me nervous. I see where you're coming from, but I'm not turning my lights off to warn someone. I'll high beam them if they've got their's on. But I'll also high beam them to warn. (Not often, at all).

Zimmeress Make Me Laugh
02/09/14 1:46 pm

And it's not legal to flash them here. But I do it anyway.

Zod Above Pugetropolis
02/09/14 1:50 pm

I was thinking daytime. At night they're on their own, because flashing the brights is just going to make them think they have theirs on and get me flashed back half the time. I wouldn't turn off the lights to warn them at night either.

vfabrizio613 Probably in my basement
02/07/14 9:39 pm

Why the hell would flashing headlights be illegal?

Reply
KAnne Atlantic City, NJ
02/07/14 8:56 pm

What does that have to do with the first amendment?

political Georgia
02/07/14 9:48 pm

Freedom of speech. Flashing lights was considered to be speech.

KAnne Atlantic City, NJ
02/07/14 9:53 pm

I don't see how? It's just a friendly warning signal.

political Georgia
02/07/14 9:54 pm

It is just communication like writing or sign language which are protected by freedom of speech.

KAnne Atlantic City, NJ
02/07/14 9:57 pm

I guess it just seems weird to me because I feel like freedom of speech protects against things that might be considered wrong by other people. Whereas I equate flashing lights like going "hey watch out!"

bwiesner Aurora, IL
02/07/14 10:52 am

Sometimes my friend flashes his brights at people driving by when there's no cop around, then we watch them hit the brakes or even wave in thanks for no reason. Then we laugh at them like the a-holes we are.

Reply
cowboy Doors of Perception
02/07/14 10:14 am

An American court really wasted their time, and tax payer's money on that? Dear Lord.

Reply
dale41 Grand Master of FIRSTS
02/07/14 7:51 am

I do it all the time for people.

Reply
Alph4omega
02/07/14 4:58 am

sure, but it's still rude as hell

pandaxoxo Colorado
02/07/14 5:40 am

How is that rude?

whitepuppy Happy Birthday
02/07/14 7:26 am

A court in Missouri

bluerum29 optimistic idealist
02/06/14 7:51 pm

The police departments just get mad because it costs them money, but it slows people down and helps to not ruin peoples day with a ticket and a meeting with the boss for being late to work, fucking traffic cops

Reply
Wackacrat Harford County
02/06/14 5:28 pm

What if there is a tree in the road around the corner and I wish to warn people to slow down and proceed cautiously? I was taught in drivers ed to flash my lights. Besides, what if I accidentally hit my high beams on by accident? What is the harm...

Reply
Wackacrat Harford County
02/06/14 5:30 pm

Of having the potential of slower and more cautious drivers? Is this not what police are on the road for? And I am such a nice guy I will do it for free.

EarlyBird Portland
02/06/14 5:20 pm

I'm very grateful to the people who have signaled to me of an upcoming speed trap.

Reply
political Georgia
02/06/14 5:31 pm

If flashing your lights is unconstitutional, I would be afraid that shooting a bird would be unconstitutional. Lol

EarlyBird Portland
02/06/14 5:36 pm

Please don't ever shoot me, poli :))

political Georgia
02/06/14 5:37 pm

Don't pull out in front of me then. :)

Arkansas123 Neoconservative
02/06/14 4:22 pm

The outcome is agreeable; but I have voted "no" because flashing headlights is conduct, not speech.

Reply
political Georgia
02/06/14 4:39 pm

Do you think writing is speech?

Arkansas123 Neoconservative
02/06/14 4:44 pm

I think writing falls under the First Amendment's guarantee of freedom of the press.

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_the_press_in_the_United_States

political Georgia
02/06/14 4:59 pm

Oh okay.

MJSeals J.D.
02/06/14 4:14 pm

Nada wrong with it

Reply
EarlyBird Portland
02/06/14 5:37 pm

Did you get your tooth fixed?

CalTexHawk spiral arm
02/06/14 4:03 pm

That probably does more to slow down drivers than police enforcement. Perhaps cops should ride around in unmarked cars flashing their lights?

Reply
rons WOKE is sick
02/06/14 3:55 pm

Sure is! I do it when a car is stopped on a curve or in the road pulled over. I don't do it if a cop is hiding and waiting. My road are usually local.

political Georgia
02/06/14 3:54 pm

The answer is yes. If you disagree, you are just wrong. JK.....well not about the wrong part. :)