Better post season quarterback, Eli or Peyton?
Peyton had a great yesr overall has a better record. Losing big yesterday will not affect his record
As a giant fan my heart belongs to Eli and he's better looking too
Cooper Manning is much more attractive than both of them!
Giants didn't make playoffs.. So I'd have to say Peyton lol. Overall through the regular season though.. Hmm, still going with Peyton. Eli had a terrible season pretty much with only 18 touchdowns and 28 interceptions etc..
If you just compare their post season records and performances, Eli is much better than Peyton. Higher winning percentage, more touchdowns, less interceptions, and Eli is 2-0
In the SB, Peyton is 1-2.
Peyton's been my Manning for years.