Show of HandsShow of Hands

Show Of Hands December 21st, 2025 2:36pm

What percentage of people locked up in prison do you think deserve to be there? Not just guilty vs innocent, but fair sentencing, etc.

9 Liked

Comments: Add Comment

tdUSMC Noblesville
Today: 10:32 am

I’ve been mentoring young men In prison for the last 8 years. Every prisoner I’ve met in the last 8 years deserved to be behind bars. For a criminal to actually land behind bars it always includes multiple offenses and very serious crimes.

Reply
Zheeeem Outer Banks
Today: 11:10 am

Nearly 1/3rd are there just for drugs. A small fraction of the rest are there as a consequence of mental issues, and some are there because they couldn’t afford a decent lawyer or just looked like a criminal to the jury.

Reply
zimmy Florida
Today: 12:06 pm

Probably 40%

Reply
mark4
Today: 8:28 am

I’ve spent many hours in prisons (HEY! Don’t get ahead of me here!) repairing equipment and talking to prisoners, everything from maximum security on down. Everyone I met was innocent.😲 Some few would tell me so with a smile.😇 Are some there unjustly? Well,people are people after all. My guess is that the most popular response is correct.

Reply
Texas1 did not proofread
Today: 8:45 am

The political split at one hour in on this poll is wild!

Reply
lcamino Florida and Georgia
Today: 10:32 am

70% Months can be spent waiting for trial, with no sentence. A lot of politics can be involved with the prosecution, involving charges and plea deals. Not that many go to trial, or can pay for a better attorney. I doubt some convictions, where there is reasonable doubt. Not many people can pay to fight a sentence. A more sympathetic person may get a lighter sentence than one the judge, prosecutor, or jury doesn’t like.

ptellini GET OVER HERE
Today: 12:01 pm

So you look at it as you don't agree with the law while it could also look at this as whether the person is innocent or guilty.

CudOfCow Oregon
Today: 12:26 pm

The prison system is worse than the education system.

TomM
Today: 1:39 pm

As far as I know there are still many for drug offenses with life sentences from the three strikes laws. To me using drugs should not in itself count as a strike and they should rather be in treatment than prison.

Regarding the vote I just put 70%. I have no idea what I would vote with more info, it’s a bit random number.

makem Chinese Xinjiang Camp
Today: 9:29 am

I'd guess 1/3. The more minor crimes could do with more creative punishments and the most severe could do with more corporal punishments.

daverator Connecticut
Today: 9:50 am

No justice system is perfect, but ours is pretty damn close to as good as it gets in terms of trials and such. I’d say somewhere in the 70-80% range? I can be convinced otherwise, just spitballing.